The most important nutrient for optimal plant growth is nitrogen (N), but it is known that in intensive agricultural systems there is an environmental risk caused by inadequate management of N fertilization (Neeteson and Carton, 2001). Processes such as nitrate leaching and nitrous oxide emissions produce major environmental problems in water and the atmosphere (Guo et al., 2010; Ramos et al., 2002). On the other hand, other agricultural inputs such as pesticides can be harmful to nontarget organisms and can produce adverse effects on human health and the environment if used negligently. Regulations set by the European Union for the sustainable use of fertilizers and pesticides to reduce risks and to lessen the impact on human health and the environment (European Union, 1991, 2009, respectively) may increase the use of biostimulants as replacements for many ingredients that are being rejected for use in turfgrass. However, the term “biostimulant” is wide and loosely defined (Mueller and Kussow, 2005). The term includes an array of products, from seaweed to cultured living microorganisms and various natural chemicals and compounds (du Jardin, 2015; Karnok, 2000; Van Oosten et al., 2017).
Calvo et al. (2014) extensively reported on the agricultural uses of plant biostimulants. Specifically, biostimulants have already been positively tested in horticulture. Battacharyya et al. (2015) reviewed the effects of seaweed extracts on vegetable, fruit, and ornamental crops—including tall fescue (Festuca arundinacea) and creeping bentgrass (Agrostis stolonifera)—and concluded that there are a number of questions that still need to be addressed for the better use of seaweed resources and their extracts in horticultural crops.
Another review of the effect of biostimulants based on humic and fulvic acids on 30 horticulture crops concluded that the use of such biostimulants in horticultural crops is a key sustainable technology that can make cropping systems more productive, efficient, and less harmful to the environment (Canellas et al., 2015). Protein hydrolysates (a mixture of peptides and amino acids) have also been positively used as biostimulants for making horticultural crops more sustainable (Colla et al., 2015, 2017).
Finally, the use of soil microorganisms (bacteria or fungus) as biostimulants for increasing the nutrient and water-use efficiency of horticultural crops has also been successfully tested (Acikgoz et al., 2016; López-Bucio, et al., 2015; Rouphael et al., 2015; Ruzzi and Aroca, 2015; Sahin and Turan, 2013). Yadav et al. (2017) reported that the use of plant growth promoting bacteria (Azotobacter, Bacillus, and Pseudomonas, and other genera) may prove useful in developing strategies to facilitate plant growth under normal conditions, as well as under abiotic stress. Another area of potential enhancement of N nutrition in turfgrasses and adaptation to environmental stress involves associative N fixation by bacteria and mycorrhizal fungi (Duncan and Carrow, 1999). Contributing to other positive roles, Azotobacter vinelandii, for example, can be used as soil contaminant detoxification bacteria (Ehaliotis et al., 1999).
Due to the success of biostimulants in vegetable and fruit crops, the biostimulant industry is focusing on turfgrass species, as there is a considerable business opportunity due to acreage and pesticide reduction regulations in this sector. However, many biostimulants marketed for turfgrass include mineral fertilizers that mask the effect of biostimulants on turfgrass, and which together with the large number of available products is making the use of biostimulants confusing for scientists, greenskeepers, and householders.
One of the most important turfgrass species in the temperate regions of the world is perennial ryegrass (Lolium perenne). This grass is suitable for home lawns, parks, cemeteries, roadsides, golf courses, and athletic fields (Wu et al., 2005). Perennial ryegrass is a cool-season turfgrass species, and its growth often is limited by high temperatures during summer months in warm climates (Jiang and Huang, 2001). A perennial ryegrass stand stressed by heat and/or other abiotic factors is more likely to be infected by diverse microorganisms, and the lack of pesticides is leading groundskeepers to apply biostimulants with little knowledge of their mechanism of action or how to integrate application procedures with other management practices (above all mowing and irrigation).
Little research has been conducted on the effect of biostimulants on perennial ryegrass. Kauffman et al. 2007 demonstrated that amino acid containing biostimulants when applied sequentially to perennial ryegrass foliage could positively affect turfgrass heat stress tolerance. Botta (2013) reported that an amino acid-based biostimulant applied on heat-stressed perennial ryegrass showed superior photosynthetic efficiency and maintained higher levels of chlorophylls and carotenoids. Another amino acid (gamma aminobutyric acid) was foliar applied on drought-stressed perennial ryegrass, demonstrating that it was effective in mitigating the physiological response of drought stress damage (Krishnan et al., 2013). Acikgoz et al. (2016) conducted a study on perennial ryegrass and tall fescue that resulted in an increase of color ratings and clipping yields when treated with plant growth-promoting rhizobacteria. Several studies have been performed on perennial ryegrass for salt tolerance enhancement by applying biostimulants: Hu et al. 2012 found glycine betaine treatments useful in this type of stress and Sun et al. (2015) and Wu et al. (2017) suggested that a 24-epibrassinolide treatment (a plant hormone) might improve perennial ryegrass salt tolerance.
Biostimulants have also been tested on other important turfgrass species. Elliot and Prevatte (1996) reported no positive effects for seaweed extracts on hybrid bermudagrass (Cynodon dactylon × C. transvaalensis) growth or quality. In tall fescue, seaweed extracts improved post-transplant rooting and quality of tall fescue sod (Zhang et al., 2003a). In creeping bentgrass, Aamlid et al. (2017) reported a faster grow-in on plots receiving amino acid-based biostimulants than on plots receiving mineral fertilizers. Xu and Huang (2010) reported improved turfgrass quality with sea plant extracts and microorganisms. However, a previous experiment (Aamlid and Hanslin, 2009) indicated that, on average, none of the tested biostimulants caused significant improvements in the overall impression of turfgrass [creeping bentgrass, perennial ryegrass, and kentucky bluegrass (Poa pratensis)] compared with control mineral fertilizer treatments. Only few improvements in foliar N uptake were reported by Stiegler et al. (2013) when single amino acid-based biostimulants were applied and compared with mineral fertilizers on creeping bentgrass. These last authors also reported that glycine was better absorbed than potassium nitrate, but none of the studied amino acid-based biostimulants exceeded urea N absorption. Another negative effect on creeping bentgrass due to a microbial inoculant biostimulant application was a delay in germination (Butler et al., 2007) or a N leaching increase when establishing a new golf green (Butler et al., 2012). Zhang et al. (2003b) and Zhang and Ervin (2008) reported that seaweed extracts and humic substances may be beneficial supplements for reducing standard fertilizer and fungicide inputs, while maintaining adequate health for creeping bentgrass. Zhang et al. (2013b) indicated a positive role for foliar amino acids in creeping bentgrass N summer fertilization programs.
Hence there is a need to improve our understanding of the function of biostimulants so that the efficacy of these materials can be improved and industrial processes can be optimized (Brown and Saa, 2015). The main research trend dealing with biostimulants on turfgrass science is in demonstrating that biostimulants are useful when applied before stress situations (heat, drought, disease, and nutrition) to reduce polluting agricultural inputs such as fertilizers and pesticides. A priority for many turfgrass managers is to maintain high-quality turfgrass while minimizing their environmental risk.
The objective of our research was to test three commercial biostimulants on perennial ryegrass in greenhouse conditions considering two hypotheses: 1) the biostimulants increase turfgrass quality, and 2) the use of these biostimulants under nutritional stress reduces mineral fertilization in a turfgrass fertilization program.
AamlidT.S.HanslinH.M.2009Evaluation of organic fertilizers and biostimulants on sand-based golf greens and football pitches under Scandinavian climate conditionsIntl. Turfgrass Soc. Res. J.11919931
AamlidT.S.KvalbeinA.PettersenT.2017Evaluation of an amino-acid-based fertilizer for grow-in of creeping bentgrass putting greensCrop Sci.5714
AcikgozE.BilgiliU.SahinF.GuillardK.2016Effect of plant growth-promoting Bacillus sp. on color and clipping yield of three turfgrass speciesJ. Plant Nutr.3914041411
ButlerT.PurcellM.HunterA.2007Microbial inoculant and biostimulant impact on turfgrass growth, morphology and stress tolerance when applied pre-germinationActa Hort.7625561
ButlerT.MwabadabaK.HunterA.2012The influence of biostimulants on nutrient leaching from a USGA golf green during the grow-in yearActa Hort.938161167
CanellasL.P.OlivaresF.L.AguiarN.O.JonesD.L.NebbiosoA.MazzeiP.PiccoloA.2015Humic and fulvic acids as biostimulants in horticultureScientia Hort.1961527
ChristiansN.E.MartinD.P.WilkinsonJ.F.1979Nitrogen, phosphorus, and potassium effects on quality and growth of kentucky bluegrass and creeping bentgrassAgron. J.71564567
CollaG.NardiS.CardarelliM.ErtaniA.LuciniL.CanaguierR.RouphaelY.2015Protein hydrolysates as biostimulants in horticultureScientia Hort.962838
CollaG.HoaglandL.RuzziM.CardarelliM.BoniniP.CanaguierR.RouphaelY.2017Biostimulant action of protein hydrolysates: Unraveling their effects on plant physiology and microbiomeFront. Plant Sci.82202
DelićD.Stajković-SrbinovićO.KuzmanovićD.RasulićN.MaksimovićS.RadovićJ.SimićA.2013Influence of plant growth promoting rhizobacteria on alfalfa Medicago sativa L. yield by inoculation of a preceding italian ryegrass Lolium multiflorum Lam. p. 333–339. In: S. Barth and D. Milbourne (eds.). Breeding strategies for sustainable forage and turf grass improvement. Springer Dordrecht The Netherlands
EhaliotisC.PapadopoulouK.KotsouM.MariI.BalisC.1999Adaptation and population dynamics of Azotobacter vinelandii during aerobic biological treatment of olive-mill wastewaterFEMS Microbiol. Ecol.30301311
European Union1991Directive 1991/676/EEC of the Council directive of 12 December 1991 concerning the protection of waters against pollution caused by nitrates from agricultural sources. Official J. European Communities L375:1–8
European Union2009Directive 2009/128/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 21 October 2009 establishing a framework for community action to achieve the sustainable use of pesticides. Official J. European Union L309:71–86
GuoR.NendelC.RahnC.JiangC.ChenQ.2010Tracking nitrogen losses in a greenhouse crop rotation experiment in north China using the EU-Rotate N simulation modelEnviron. Pollut.15822182229
HuL.HuT.ZhangX.PangH.FuJ.2012Exogenous glycine betaine ameliorates adverse effects of salt stress on perennial ryegrassJ. Amer. Soc. Hort. Sci.1373846
JiangY.HuangB.2001Physiological responses to heat and stress alone or in combination with drought: A comparison between tall fescue and perennial ryegrassHortScience34682686
KauffmanG.L.KneivelD.P.WatschkeT.L.2007Effects of a biostimulant on the heat tolerance associated with photosynthetic capacity, membrane thermostability, and polyphenol production of perennial ryegrassCrop Sci.47261267
KrishnanS.LaskowskiK.ShuklaV.MerewitzE.B.2013Mitigation of drought stress damage by exogenous application of a non-protein amino acid γ–aminobutyric acid on perennial ryegrassJ. Amer. Soc. Hort. Sci.138358366
López-BucioJ.Pelagio-FloresR.Herrera-EstrellaA.2015Trichoderma as biostimulant: Exploiting the multilevel properties of a plant beneficial fungusScientia Hort.196109123
MahdaviS.KafiM.FallahiE.ShokrpourM.TabriziL.2017Drought and biostimulant impacts on mineral nutrients, ambient and reflected light-based chlorophyll index, and performance of perennial ryegrassJ. Plant Nutr.4022482258
MorrisK.N.ShearmanR.C.1998NTEP turfgrass evaluation guidelines p. 1–5. In: NTEP Turfgrass Evaluation Wkshp. Natl. Turfgrass Evaluation Program Beltsville MD
MuellerS.R.KussowW.R.2005Biostimulants influences on turfgrass microbial communities and creeping bentgrass putting green qualityHortScience4019041910
NeetesonJ.J.CartonO.T.2001The environmental impact of nitrogen in field vegetable production. In international conference on environmental problems associated with nitrogen fertilisation of field grown vegetable cropsActa Hort.5632128
PodileA.R.KishoreA.K.2007Plant growth-promoting rhizobacteria p. 195–230. In: S.S. Gnanamanickam (ed.). Plant-associated bacteria. Springer Dordrecht The Netherlands
RouphaelY.FrankenP.SchneiderC.SchwarzD.GiovanettiM.AgnolucciM.De PascaleS.BoniniP.CollaG.2015Arbuscular mycorrhizal fungi act as biostimulants in horticultural cropsScientia Hort.19691108
SahinF.TuranM.2013Use of plant growth promoting rhizobacteria PGPR to improve effectiveness of chemical fertilizers on spring wheat and barley in the field condition. 48th Croatian and 8th Intl. Symp. Agr. 17–22 Feb. 2013 Dubrovnik Croatia. p. 4
StieglerJ.C.RichardsonM.D.KarcherD.E.2013Foliar absorption of various inorganic and organic nitrogen sources by creeping bentgrassCrop Sci.5311481152
Van OostenM.J.PepeO.De PascaleS.SillettiS.MaggioA.2017The role of biostimulants and bioeffectors as alleviators of abiotic stress in crop plantsChem. Biol. Technol. Agr.45
WuY.-Y.ChenQ.-J.ChenM.ChenJ.WangX.-C.2005Salt-tolerant transgenic perennial ryegrass (Lolium perenne L.) obtained by Agrobacterium tumefaciens-mediated transformation of the vacuolar Na+/H+ antiporter genePlant Sci.1696573
WuW.ZhangQ.ErvinE.H.YangZ.ZhangX.2017Physiological mechanism of enhancing salt tolerance of perennial ryegrass by 24-epibrassinolideFront. Plant Sci.81017
YadavA.N.VermaP.SinghB.ChauahanV.S.SumanA.SaxenaA.K.2017Plant growth promoting bacteria: Biodiversity and multifunctional attributes for sustainable agricultureAdv. Biotechnol. Microbiol.5116
ZhangX.ErvinE.H.SchmidtR.E.2003aSeaweed extract, humic acid, and propiconazole improve tall fescue sod heat tolerance and posttransplant qualityHortScience38440443
ZhangX.ErvinE.H.SchmidtR.E.2003bPhysiological effects of liquid applications of a seaweed extract and a humic acid on creeping bentgrassJ. Amer. Soc. Hort. Sci.128492496
ZhangX.ErvinE.H.2008Impact of seaweed extract-based cytokinins and zeatin riboside on creeping bentgrass heat toleranceCrop Sci.48364370
ZhangX.LiuW.SchloterM.ZhangG.ChenQ.HuangJ.LiL.ElserJ.J.HanX.2013aResponse of the abundance of key soil microbial nitrogen-cycling genes to multi-factorial global changesPLoS One8e76500
ZhangX.SummerP.ErvinE.H.2013bFoliar amino acid-based fertilizer impact on creeping bentgrass drought resistanceIntl. Turfgrass Soc. Res. J.1217