Abstract
Results suggest that sand topdressing was more consistent at reducing dollar spot (Clarireedia jacksonii) in fairway turfgrass more so than rolling. This practice could be an effective cost-saving alternative to reduce frequent fungicide applications. Research was conducted from 2011 to 2014 on a simulated golf fairway and examined dollar spot severity responses in a mixed-stand of creeping bentgrass (Agrostis stolonifera) and annual bluegrass (Poa annua ssp. reptans) to sand topdressing and rolling. Treatments consisted of biweekly sand topdressing, rolling at three frequencies (one, three, or five times weekly), a control, and three replications. Infection was visually estimated. Sand topdressing significantly (P < 0.05) reduced disease up to 50% at the peak of the dollar spot activity in 2011, 2013, and 2014. Results on the effects of rolling on dollar spot were inconsistent.
Turfgrass health is a major concern for golf course managers. Dollar spot (Salgado-Salazar et al., 2018; Smiley et al., 1992) is the most common foliar disease in the upper Midwest affecting turfgrass quality and playability resulting in the expenditure of millions of dollars for frequent fungicide applications (Goodman and Burpee, 1991; Vargas, 2005). Although infections can occur in both warm and cool season grasses worldwide, turfgrass managers commonly limit fungicide use due to economic, environmental, and fungicide resistance concerns (Delvalle et al., 2011; Detweiler et al., 1983; Golembiewski et al., 1995; Warren et al., 1974). The increasing cost and probable ban of certain chemical pesticides by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (2011) are causing turf managers to seek effective yet inexpensive means to control turf diseases. Research on alternative management strategies has given credence to cultural practices that not only promote plant health, but also are antagonistic to the pathogens (Giordano et al., 2012). Primary cultural practices that optimize fertilization, irrigation, and mowing have been shown to decrease dollar spot (Bennett, 1937; Couch 1962, 1966; Couch and Bloom, 1960; Endo, 1963; Landschoot and McNitt, 1997; Liu et al., 1995; Markland et al., 1969; Williams et al., 1996). Supplementary cultural practices such as sand topdressing effectively reduce dollar spot as well (Skorulski et al., 2010). Perhaps other supplementary cultural practices (cultivation and rolling) could be viable alternatives to chemical pesticide applications, thus decreasing the necessity, extending the efficacy, and reducing possible human exposure to these chemicals (Giordano et al., 2012), so that instead of applying eight to nine fungicide treatments per season at a cost of $16,000 to $27,000 annually on fairways (Turfgrass Producers International, 2011), sand topdressing may alleviate this annual expenditure, and possibly decrease cost per application by 25% to 50%. Although perhaps not as effective as conventional, chemical pest management systems, certain culture practices have proven to be acceptable disease management strategies in terms of playing conditions (Rossi and Grant, 2009).
One of the earliest turf mechanical practices was rolling of the green. It was typically used to smooth surface imperfections, and predated mechanical mowing (Beard et al., 2014). The practice of rolling became routine on sport turfgrass by the turn of the 20th century (Beard et al., 2014), yet the advent of new mowers in the late 1920s and the fear of compaction led to the decline of rollers and was almost nonexistent until the 1990s for tournament play (Beard et al., 2014). From a modern golf perspective, lightweight rolling has been used to increase ball roll distance (Nikolai et al., 2001) by smoothing the putting green surface. Whether rolling is applied daily or weekly, a device of varying force per unit area (from 6.5 to 14.2 psi) and design configuration (this includes rollers on mowers) is often used on a putting green. In the mid-1990s, researchers discovered that rolling at a frequency of three times weekly reduced dollar spot, and localized dry spot, moss, and broadleaf weeds in creeping bentgrass (Nikolai et al., 2001). Inguagiato et al. (2009) observed that rolling decreased the severity of anthracnose (Colletotrichum cereale), whereas Roberts et al. (2012) reported that rolling not only increased ball roll distance, but also reduced anthracnose in annual bluegrass putting greens. These experiments demonstrated that turfgrass edaphic environment and pathogen activity could be affected by rolling practices. However, the mechanisms surrounding the effects of rolling on disease suppression remain unknown.
The objective of the study was to evaluate the efficacy of sand topdressing and rolling on dollar spot severity in a mixed-sward creeping bentgrass and annual bluegrass fairway. Different rolling frequency and sand topdressing treatments were used to garner data that would help validate that dollar spot severity would be decreased by sand topdressing and by rolling.
Materials and methods
Field research on the effects of sand topdressing and rolling on dollar spot severity in fairway turfgrass was conducted May through Oct. 2011 to 2014 at the Hancock Turfgrass Research Center, East Lansing, MI. The experimental site was a mixed-stand simulated golf fairway of 60% creeping bentgrass and 40% annual bluegrass seeded in 2009. The native soil of this site is Capac loam (fine loamy, mixed, mesic Aquic Glossudalfs) with a cation exchange capacity of 15 meq/100 g, pH of 7.8, bulk density of 1.5 g·cm−3, and particle analysis of 50% sand, 24% silt, and 26% clay
The experiment was a two-way factorial, split-plot randomized complete block design with three replications (Fig. 1). The whole plot factor was sand topdressing. Six plots (60 × 95 ft) were either sand topdressed or not topdressed (native soil) with biweekly applications May through September at 0.14 yard3/1000 ft2. A sand layer of 1.4 inches was accumulated over a 4-year period (Table 1). Four subplots measuring 12 × 16 ft were randomized within each whole plot and assigned rolling treatments of one, three, and five times weekly plus control. A triplex mower (model 2500A; Deere & Co., Moline, IL) with vibratory rollers (Turfline, Moscow, MO) was used in this experiment. This unit had a 5.0-ft swath, vertical force value of 4.5 psi (31.03 kPa), and weighed 1298 lb.
Particle size distribution of sand used to topdress creeping bentgrass and annual bluegrass in 2015.
The site was maintained as a typical Michigan golf course fairway, mowed (clippings not collected) three times weekly at 0.5 inch, and if no rain events occurred, 0.15 inch of water was applied in a single irrigation period May through October. Herbicides and insecticides were applied as needed, but fungicides were not applied for the duration of the study. Azoxystrobin was applied only to discourage gray snow mold (Typhula incarnata) at the end of each growing season. The site was not core cultivated for the duration of the study to minimize surface disruption and soil displacement.
Liquid and granular fertilizer formulations were used to supply nitrogen (N) and elemental phosphorus (P) and potassium (K) to the site. In 2011, urea fertilizer 46N–0P–0K (3.0 lb/1000 ft2 N) was used; however, the formulation was substituted for a urea-ammonium nitrate 28N–0P–0K (1.6 lb/1000 ft2 N) the following season, remaining as such for the duration of this study. Applications of polymer-coated urea (PCU) fertilizer 29N–0P–8.3K (1.25 lb/1000 ft2 N) were included on 20 July 2013 and 7 June 2014. In addition, a PCU fertilizer 29N–0.9P–7.5K (1.1 lb/1000 ft2 N) was applied on 29 Aug. 2014.
During the first two seasons of the study, in 2011 and 2012, naturally occurring dollar spot was prevalent, but in 2013 and 2014, the site was artificially inoculated to encourage uniform disease coverage using the Goodman and Burpee (1991) technique. After a 10-d incubation period, this concoction of silica sand, cornmeal, potato dextrose agar, and dollar spot VCG-B (Powell and Vargas, 2001) inoculum was applied at a rate of 9.0 lb/1000 ft2 using a drop-spreader (model 36H13; Gandy Co, Owatonna, MN).
Plots were visually rated for dollar spot severity on a 0% (no dollar spot observed) to 100% (entire plot area blighted) scale. Area under the disease progress curve (AUDPC) values were assessed by the following:
Results
Significant main effects of sand topdressing and rolling on dollar spot severity were observed. In 2011, sand topdressing treatment significantly reduced dollar spot severity compared with the non-topdress plots (Table 2). High-frequency rolling reduced dollar spot when compared with the control on 2 Sept. A sand topdressing × rolling frequency interaction was observed in which three and five times weekly rolling treatments in combination with sand topdressing significantly reduced dollar spot (Fig. 2) compared with the once per week rolling treatment.
Effects of sand topdressing and rolling frequency on dollar spot severity in creeping bentgrass and annual bluegrass in 2011 at East Lansing, MI.
Main effects of topdressing and rolling frequency were significant in 2012 (Table 3). Sand topdressing reduced dollar spot compared with non-topdress plots on 16 Sept. Contrary to the overall trend observed in 2011, dollar spot was most severe on the plots that received the high-frequency rolling treatments. More so dollar spot pressure was considerably lower in 2012, in part due to high air temperatures and below average precipitation (Table 4) that adversely affected both the fungus and turfgrass despite efforts to supply adequate irrigation amounts to the research site.
Effects of sand topdressing and rolling frequency on dollar spot severity in creeping bentgrass and annual bluegrass in 2012 at East Lansing, MI.
Seasonal precipitation amounts received June to September at the Hancock Turfgrass Research Center, East Lansing, MI.z
Main effects of sand topdressing and rolling frequency were observed on several collection dates in 2013 as well as a significant sand topdressing × rolling frequency interactions (Table 5). When compared with the control, the sand topdressing treatment notably reduced dollar spot severity by 34% and 66% on 21 and 30 Aug., respectively. During this period, ideal climatic conditions for an epidemic of dollar spot were experienced (Table 6). Thus, rolling five times per week resulted in lower dollar spot severity in comparison with the control and the one and three time weekly rolling treatments on 22 July and 21 Aug. Furthermore, as rolling frequency increased on the sand topdressed plots, dollar spot severity was drastically reduced compared with the non-topdressed plots that received similar rolling treatments (Fig. 3).
Effects of sand topdressing and rolling frequency on dollar spot severity in creeping bentgrass and annual bluegrass in 2013 at East Lansing, MI.
Seasonal climatic conditions at the Hancock Turfgrass Research Center in 2013 at East Lansing, MI.z
Significant main effects of sand topdressing were observed in 2014; however, rolling frequency results were not significant. Only one collection date was observed in which sand topdressing reduced disease by 46% compared with the control (Table 7).
Effects of sand topdressing and rolling frequency on dollar spot severity in creeping bentgrass and annual bluegrass in 2014 at East Lansing, MI.
The AUDPC was calculated for 2011 to 2014 (Table 8). Main and interaction effects of sand topdress and rolling frequency were significant in 2011. Plots that were sand topdressed and rolled either three or five times weekly had less dollar spot compared with non-topdress plots with similar rolling treatments (Fig. 4). Sand topdressing decreased dollar spot when compared with the non-topdress plots. Subsequent seasons did not result in significant treatment effects.
Effects of sand topdressing and rolling frequency on the area under the disease progress curve (AUDPC) for the severity of dollar spot in creeping bentgrass and annual bluegrass at East Lansing, MI.
Discussion
Results from our study were similar to Skorulski et al. (2010), in which sand topdressing reduced dollar spot severity and increased turfgrass quality, color, and density in a fairway turf. Others have observed significant reductions of anthracnose in annual bluegrass fairway plots with regular sand topdressing (Hempfling et al., 2015). Some researchers have speculated that the sand particle shape and topdressing incorporation method exacerbate turf disease severity response, but Inguagiato et al. (2013) found that neither the sand shape nor the method of incorporation enhanced anthracnose severity. More so they noticed that routine sand topdressing reduced anthracnose severity in annual bluegrass putting greens. In another study, Inguagiato et al. (2012) found that comparatively low sand rates applied at short intervals substantially reduced anthracnose. Perhaps these seasonal accumulations of sand topdressing not only dilute thatch (Beard, 1973; Ledeboer and Skogley, 1967), but also dilute the fungal stroma of dollar spot, the primary means of pathogen survival and dissemination (Vargas, 2005). Some speculate that sand topdressing produces a favorable microclimate for thatch decomposition within the turf canopy and upper rhizosphere (Ledeboer and Skogley, 1967). Dilution of this thatch layer (McCarty et al., 2005) also has been shown to be an important aspect in dealing with the accumulation of this substance (Couillard et al., 1997), in which excessive amounts have been attributed to numerous turfgrass deficiencies such as increased localized dry spot (Cornman, 1952), intensified disease incidence (Beard, 1973; Murray and Juska, 1977), and adversely affected water infiltration rates (Murray and Juska, 1977).
Despite claims that rolling and sand topdressing significantly reduce turf disease severity (Inguagiato et al., 2009; Nikolai et al., 2001; Skorulski et al., 2010), the effects of rolling on dollar spot severity were inconsistent in this study. Nevertheless, sand topdressing was more consistent at reducing dollar spot severity in turf plots. There is a dearth of research addressing lightweight rolling effects on fairway turf, particularly the mechanism involved in dollar spot suppression. Major differences between turf found in fairways and putting greens include the height and frequency of cut, and the intensity of cultural practices that affect thatch accumulations. In most circumstances, a putting green will have less thatch. Therefore, rolling intensity and/or the mechanical forces involved in rolling fairways might have to be greater to affect this edaphic environment. Many people believe leaf exudate (guttation) and dew that accumulate on the leaf surface provide sustenance for diseases such as brown patch and dollar spot (Monteith and Dahl, 1932; Williams et al., 1996). Consequently, most golf course superintendents regularly remove dew from the turf surface using many different techniques, such as dragging, whipping, rolling, or irrigation (Vargas, 2005). Nevertheless, researchers have reported that displacement of leaf surface moisture has some effect on disease incidence, and dew removal by mechanical wiping of foliage, and morning mowing not only reduces brown patch in perennial ryegrass [Lolium perenne (Settle et al., 2001)], but also reduces dollar spot in creeping bentgrass (Delvalle et al., 2011; Williams et al., 1996).
Perhaps rolling affects soil porosity (Ball et al., 1988; Beard, 1973) and matric potential (Hillel, 1998) with sand-based root zones benefiting from these compaction operations (Giordano et al., 2012; Nikolai et al., 2001). Studies have shown that sand textured (80% sand, 10% peat, 10% soil) plots that were rolled had increased percentage of water retention in comparison with the nonrolled plots (Nikolai et al., 2001). Therefore, mechanisms by which rolling is suppressive to the dollar spot pathogen could be the effect of soil moisture levels mitigating drought-stress–related disease epidemics (Couch, 1966; Couch and Bloom, 1960; Dykema, 2014), or the effect of beneficial microorganisms that proliferate in the turfgrass edaphic environment, as proposed by Giordano et al. (2012). Moreover, our observations support earlier statements that drought-stressed turf is more susceptible to a variety of turf diseases that, in effect, cause a noticeable decrease of turfgrass quality (Couch, 1966; Couch and Bloom, 1960). It is still arguable as to how certain cultural practices affect turfgrass diseases. In an unpublished research study, we combined sand topdressing and rolling with a fungicide to investigate probable decreases in annual fungicide usage and deduced that sand topdressing alone or in combination with a fungicide could be a viable alternative for controlling dollar spot in a golf course fairway. Although it may not be prudent to compare the cost and control equivalent of synthetic fungicides to that of sand topdressing, in regions with pesticide restrictions, any degree of disease suppression is better than none.
Units
Literature cited
Ball, B.C., O’Sullivan, M.F. & Hunter, R. 1988 Gas diffusion, flow fluid, and derived pore continuity indices in relation to vehicle traffic and tillage J. Soil Sci. 39 327 339
Beard, J.B. 1973 Turfgrass: Science and culture. Prentice-Hall, Englewood Cliffs, NJ
Beard, J.B., Beard, H.J. & Beard, J.C. 2014 Turfgrass history and literature: Lawns, sports, and golf. Michigan State Univ. Press, East Lansing, MI
Bennett, F.T. 1937 Dollarspot disease of turf and its causal organism, Sclerotinia homoeocarpa N. sp Ann. Appl. Biol. 24 236 257
Campbell, C.L. & Madden, L.V. 1990 Introduction to plant disease epidemiology. Wiley, New York, NY
Cornman, J.F. 1952 Mat formation on putting greens Golf Course Rpt. 20 4 394 401
Couch, H.B. & Bloom, J.R. 1960 Influence of environment on diseases of turfgrasses. II. Effect of nutrition, pH, and soil moisture on Sclerotinia dollar spot Phytopathology 50 761 763
Couch, H.B. 1962 Disease of turfgrasses. Reinhold, New York, NY
Couch, H.B. 1966 Relationship between soil moisture, nutrition, and severity of turfgrass diseases J. Sports Turf Res. Inst. 42 54 64
Couillard, A., Turgeon, A.J. & Rieke, P.E. 1997 New insights into thatch biodegradation Intl. Turfgrass Soc. Res. J. 8 427 435
Delvalle, T.C., Landschoot, P.J. & Kaminski, J.E. 2011 Effects of dew removal and mowing frequency on fungicide performance for dollar spot control Plant Dis. 95 1427 1432
Detweiler, A.R., Vargas, J.M. Jr & Danneberger, T.K. 1983 Resistance of Sclerotinia homoeocarpa to iprodione and benomyl Plant Dis. 67 627 630
Dykema, N.M. 2014 Impact of irrigation regime and host cultivar on dollar spot of creeping bentgrass. Michigan State Univ., East Lansing, MS Thesis
Endo, R.M. 1963 Influence of temperature on rate of growth of five fungus pathogens of turfgrass and on rate of disease spread Phytopathology 53 857 861
Giordano, P.R., Nikolai, T.A., Vargas, J.M. Jr & Hammerschmidt, R. 2012 Timing and frequency effects of lightweight rolling on dollar spot disease in creeping bentgrass putting greens Crop Sci. 52 1371 1378
Goodman, D.M. & Burpee, L.L. 1991 Biological control of dollar spot disease of creeping bentgrass Phytopathology 81 1438 1446
Golembiewski, R.C., Vargas, J.M. Jr, Jones, A.L. & Detweiler, A.R. 1995 Detection of demethylation inhibitor (DMI) resistance in Sclerotinia homoeocarpa populations Plant Dis. 79 491 493
Hempfling, J.W., Clarke, B.B. & Murphy, J.A. 2015 Anthracnose on annual bluegrass as influenced by spring and summer topdressing Crop Sci. 55 437 443
Hillel, D. 1998 Environmental soil physics. Academic Press, San Diego, CA
Inguagiato, J.C., Murphy, J.A. & Clarke, B.B. 2009 Anthracnose disease and annual bluegrass putting green performance affected by mowing and lightweight rolling Crop Sci. 49 1454 1462
Inguagiato, J.C., Murphy, J.A. & Clarke, B.B. 2012 Sand topdressing rate and interval effects on anthracnose severity of an annual bluegrass putting green Crop Sci. 52 1406 1415
Inguagiato, J.C., Murphy, J.A. & Clarke, B.B. 2013 Topdressing sand particle shape and incorporation effects on anthracnose severity of an annual bluegrass putting green Intl. Turfgrass Soc. Res. J. 12 127 133
Landschoot, P.J. & McNitt, A.S. 1997 Effect of nitrogen fertilizers on suppression of dollar spot disease of Agrostis stolonifera L Intl. Turfgrass Soc. Res. J. 8 905 911
Ledeboer, F.B. & Skogley, C.R. 1967 Investigations into the nature of thatch and methods for its decomposition Agron. J. 59 320 323
Liu, L.X., Hsiang, T., Carey, K. & Eggens, J.L. 1995 Microbial populations and suppression of dollar spot disease in creeping bentgrass with inorganic and organic amendments Plant Dis. 79 144 147
Markland, F.E., Roberts, E.C. & Fredrick, L.R. 1969 Influence of nitrogen fertilizers on washington creeping bentgrass, Agrostis palustris Huds. II. Incidence of dollar spot, Sclerotinia homoeocarpa, infection Agron. J. 61 701 705
McCarty, L.B., Gregg, M.F., Toler, J.E., Camberato, J.J. & Hill, H.S. 2005 Minimizing thatch and mat in a newly seeded creeping bentgrass golf green Crop Sci. 45 1529 1535
Monteith, J. & Dahl, A.S. 1932 Turf diseases and their control Bul. USGA Green Sect. 12 4 394 401
Murray, J.J. & Juska, F.V. 1977 Effect of management practices on thatch accumulation, turf quality, and leaf spot damage in common kentucky bluegrass Agron. J. 69 365 369
Nikolai, T.A., Rieke, P.E., Rogers, J.N. III & Vargas J.M. Jr 2001 Turfgrass and soil responses to lightweight rolling on putting green root zone mixes Intl. Turfgrass Soc. Res. J. 9 604 609
Powell, J. & Vargas, J.M. Jr 2001 Vegetative compatibility and seasonal variation among isolates of Sclerotinia homoeocarpa Plant Dis. 85 377 381
Roberts, J.A., Murphy, J.A. & Clarke, B.B. 2012 Lightweight rolling effects on anthracnose of annual bluegrass putting greens Agron. J. 104 1176 1181
Rossi, F.S. & Grant, J.A. 2009 Long term evaluation of reduced chemical pesticide management of golf course putting turf Intl. Turfgrass Soc. Res. J. 11 77 90
Salgado-Salazar, C., Beirn, L.A., Ismaiel, A., Boehm, M.J., Carbone, I., Putman, A.I., Tredway, L.P., Clarke, B.B. & Crouch, J.A. 2018 Clarireedia: A new fungal genus comprising four pathogenic species responsible for dollar spot disease of turfgrass Fungal Biol. 122 761 773
Settle, D., Fry, J. & Tisserat, N. 2001 Effects of irrigation frequency on brown patch in perennial ryegrass Intl. Turfgrass Soc. Res. J. 9 710 714
Skorulski, J., Henderson, J. & Miller, N. 2010 Topdressing fairways: More is better USGA Green Sect. Rec. 48 2 394 401
Smiley, R.W., Dernoeden, P.H. & Clark, B.B. 1992 Compendium of turfgrass diseases, 2nd ed. APS Press, St. Paul, MN
Turfgrass Producers International 2011 State of Michigan turfgrass facts. Turfgrass Producers Intl. (TPI) E-Nwsl. 4 9
U.S. Environmental Protection Agency 2011 National Marine Fisheries Service biological opinion: Registration of pesticides 2, 4-D, triclopyr BEE, diuron, linuron, captan, and chlorothalonil Endangered Species Act. Sect. 7 3 394 401
Vargas, J.M. Jr 2005 Management of turfgrass diseases. Wiley, Hoboken, NJ
Warren, C.G., Sanders, P. & Cole, H. 1974 Sclerotinia homoeocarpa resistance to benzimidazole configuration fungicides Phytopathology 64 1139 1142
Westfall, P.H., Tobias, R.D., Rom, D., Wolfinger, R.D. & Hochberg, Y. 1999 Multiple comparisons and multiple tests using the SAS system. SAS Inst., Cary, NC
Williams, D.W., Powell, A.J. Jr, Vincelli, P. & Dougherty, C.T. 1996 Dollar spot on bentgrass influenced by displacement of leaf surface moisture, nitrogen, and clipping removal Crop Sci. 36 1304 1309