Turfgrass species can be classified into two main groups: cool-season and warm-season species. Because of their different physiology, warm-season species need less water to produce the same dry matter weight, thus they are more suited to Mediterranean climates (Croce et al., 2004; Turgeon, 2012; Volterrani and De Bertoldi, 2012) and have superior wear resistance and recovery compared with cool-season turf species (Lulli et al., 2012).
Transplanting single-potted plants is an innovative technique developed in Italy to convert cool-season to warm-season turfgrasses (Volterrani et al., 2008). Transplanting is based on the quick groundcovering capacity by stolons and rhizomes of small turf plants grown in a nursery garden. Transplanting can be accomplished manually or mechanically, in untilled soil, and is significantly cheaper than sodding. Although transplanting is efficient in converting a cool-season turfgrass to a warm-season turfgrass when soil tillage is not performed, the previous turf has to be completely desiccated.
Desiccation is usually achieved with chemical methods, such as herbicides, and the most common active ingredients are glyphosate and glufosinate ammonium (Baldi et al., 2013; Del Viva, 2012; Volterrani et al., 2008). However, clause 16 of EU Directive 2009/128/CE strongly discourages or prohibits the use of chemical herbicides, such as glyphosate, in public gardens, parks, sport turfs, and schoolyards. As a possible alternative, turfgrass can also be desiccated using flaming and steaming as an alternative to chemical weed control in organic/integrated farming and urban hard surfaces (Bàrberi et al., 2009; Peruzzi et al., 2011, 2012; Raffaelli et al., 2013, 2016).
Weeds and turfgrass species respond differently to physical treatments depending on their particular characteristics. Grasses (Gramineae) are monocots. Monocots have evolved to develop meristems protected by several leaf sheets (Baldoin et al., 2010), whereas dicots usually have all their meristems above the ground and widely over the plant. Grass turf species are less sensitive than most dicots to physical desiccation because they grow back from the protected meristems after the treatment unlike many dicots (Melander et al., 2009; Ulloa et al., 2010a). Rask et al. (2012) found that grass turf species, such as perennial ryegrass, are difficult to control with physical methods because the parts affected are mainly above the ground. Several authors have tested the effects on sensitive species of a single treatment with different flaming doses (Ascard, 1995; Ulloa et al., 2010a, 2010b) and steaming doses (Hansson and Ascard, 2002). However, there is still very little understanding concerning the effects of such techniques on less sensitive species such as grass turf species (Rask et al., 2012). Rask and Kristoffersen (2007) suggest that more than one treatment is required to efficiently desiccate grass turf species using flaming and steaming because otherwise they recover. Flaming can also be used as an effective weed control method before turfgrass establishment (Hoyle et al., 2012).
Alternative methods to flaming and steaming have been applied and tested over the years to desiccate vegetation using physical techniques. Hansson and Ascard (2002) experimented with the use of hot water to control weeds growing in hard surfaces. Sartorato et al. (2006) applied microwaves for postemergence weed control. However, flaming is still the most frequently applied physical method to desiccate vegetation. Steaming has been described by various authors as a valid alternative to flaming (Hansson and Ascard, 2002; Kerpauskas et al., 2006) and several agricultural machines for steam application have been developed (Gay et al., 2010a, 2010b; Langshaw, 1995).
The aim of this study was to compare flaming and steaming, performed by dedicated prototype equipment, with a glufosinate-ammonium herbicide treatment to desiccate cool-season turfgrass for conversion to warm-season turfgrass in untilled soil using transplanting.
BaldiA.LenziA.NanniciniM.PardiniA.TesiR.2013Growth and nutrient content of hybrid bermudagrass grown for nursery purposes at different nitrogen, phosphorus, and potassium ratesHortTechnology23347355
BaldoinC.SartoratoI.FrisoD.De ZancheC.De PaoliF.BietresatoM.2010Weed control by water steam using a self-propelled machine equipped with a condensation chamber. Proc. XVIIth World Congr. Intl. Commission Agr. Biosystems Eng. (CIGR). Québec City QC Canada. 13–17 June 2010. CSBE100427:1–10
BàrberiP.MoonenA.C.PeruzziA.FontanelliM.RaffaelliM.2009Weed suppression by soil steaming in combination with activating compoundsWeed Res.495566
CroceP.De LucaA.MocioniM.VolterraniM.BeardJ.B.2004Adaptibility of warm-season turfgrass species and cultivars in a Mediterranean climateActa Hort.661365368
Del VivaM.2012Erbavoglio Hi Turf: Sistema avanzato di propagazione delle macroterme. Quaderno dei Georgofili. VIII edizione. Polistampa Florence Italy
FoxJ.WeisbergS.2011An R companion to applied regression. 2nd ed. Sage Thousand Oaks CA
GayP.PiccaroloP.Ricauda AimoninoD.TortiaC.2010aA high efficiency steam soil disinfestation system, part I: Physical background and steam supply optimisationBiosyst. Eng.1077485
GayP.PiccaroloP.Ricauda AimoninoD.TortiaC.2010bA high efficacy steam soil disinfestation system, part II: Design and testingBiosyst. Eng.107194201
KerpauskasP.SirvydasA.P.LazauskasP.VasinauskieneR.TamosiunasA.2006Possibilities of weed control by water steamAgron. Res.4special issue221225
KnezevicS.Z.StreibigJ.C.RitzC.2007Utilizing R software package for dose-response studies: The concept and data analysisWeed Technol.21840848
KutznetsovaA.BrockhoffB.ChristensenR.H.B.2015Tests in linear mixed effects models. 5 July 2017. <https://cran.r-project.org/web/packages/lmerTest/index.html>
LangshawE.1995Hot water/steam weed killing system. U.S. Patent 5 385 106 Chemical Abstr. 65:2870
LulliF.VolterraniM.GrossiN.ArmeniR.StefaniniS.GuglielminettiL.2012Physiological and morphological factors influencing wear resistance and recovery in C3 and C4 turfgrass speciesFunct. Plant Biol.39214221
MelanderB.HolstN.GrundyA.C.KempenaarC.RiemensM.M.VerschweleA.HanssonD.2009Weed occurrence on pavements in five North European townsWeed Res.49516525
PeruzziA.RaffaelliM.FrasconiC.FontanelliM.BàrberiP.2012Influence of an injection system on the effect of activated soil steaming on Brassica juncea and the natural weed seedbankWeed Res.52140152
PeruzziA.RaffaelliM.GinanniM.FontanelliM.FrasconiC.2011An innovative self-propelled machine for soil disinfection using steam and chemicals in an exothermic reactionBiosyst. Eng.110434442
R Core Team2016R: A language and environment for statistical computing. 21 Mar. 2016. <https://www.R-project.org>
RaffaelliM.MartelloniL.FrasconiC.FontanelliM.CarlesiS.PeruzziA.2016A prototype band-steaming machine: Design and field applicationBiosyst. Eng.1446171
RaffaelliM.MartelloniL.FrasconiC.FontanelliM.PeruzziA.2013Development of machines for flaming weed control on hard surfacesAppl. Eng. Agr.29663673
RaskA.M.AndreasenC.KristoffersenP.2012Response of Lolium perenne to repeated flame treatments with various doses of propaneWeed Res.52131139
RasmussenJ.NørremarkM.BibbyB.M.2007Assessment of leaf cover and crop soil cover in weed harrowing research using digital imagesWeed Res.47299310
SyrvidasA.LazauskasP.VasinauskieneìR.KerpauskasP.2002Thermal weed control by water steam. Proc. 5th European Weed Res. Soc. Wkshp. Physical Weed Control. Pisa Italy. 11–13 Mar. 2002. p. 253–262
TurgeonA.J.2012Turfgrass management. 9th ed. Prentice Hall Upper Saddle River NJ
UlloaS.M.DattaA.KnezevicS.Z.2010aGrowth stage influenced differential response of foxtail and pigweed species to broadcast flamingWeed Technol.24319325
UlloaS.M.DattaA.KnezevicS.Z.2010bTolerance of selected weed species to broadcast flaming at different growth stagesCrop Prot.2913811388
VolterraniM.De BertoldiC.2012I generi di macroterme per i tappeti erbosi nel bacino del Mediterraneo: CynodonPaspalum e Zoysia. Quaderno dei Georgofili VIII edizione Polistampa Florence Italy
VolterraniM.GrossiN.LulliF.GaetaniM.2008Establishment of warmseason turfgrass species by transplant of single potted plantsActa Hort.7837784
WheelerM.W.ParkR.M.BailerA.J.2005Comparing median lethal concentration values using confidence interval overlap or ratio testEnviron. Toxicol. Chem.2514411444