Farmers commonly use intensive tillage in U.S. vegetable production to prepare seedbeds, incorporate crop residue, and remove weeds. Intensive tillage, however, decreases long-term soil health, causing compaction, loss of structure, and loss of organic matter. Reducing tillage over time leads to improved soil aggregate stability, water retention, and infiltration (Arshad et al., 1999; Mendoza et al., 2008; Power et al., 1986). Reduced-till soils also have increased organic matter, nutrient retention, and biological activity compared with tilled soils (Beare et al., 1997; Franzluebbers, 2002; Gupta and Germida, 1988; Hungria et al., 2009; Tebrügge and Düring, 1999).
Despite these benefits, reduced-till in organic systems often results in lower crop yields compared with organic conventional-till systems (Halde et al., 2015; Leavitt et al., 2011), and weed management is a primary challenge constraining reduced-till adoption by organic farmers (Lowry and Brainard, 2017). Weed density and biomass are commonly higher in reduced-till systems than in conventional-till systems (Campiglia et al., 2018; Cavalaris and Gemtos, 2002; Nakamoto et al., 2006). Although conventional farmers may increase use of herbicides when reducing tillage (Buhler et al., 1994), organic farmers primarily rely on cultivation and need more alternatives for improving weed management.
Reduced-till systems can be particularly challenging for direct-seeded root crops, such as beets (Beta vulgaris L.), for which farmers often rely on a fine, residue-free seedbed for planting. Beets are also poor competitors with weeds when they first emerge, and early-season weed control is crucial for a successful crop. Sugar beet yield is often decreased in reduced-till compared with conventional-till systems (Cavalaris and Gemtos, 2002; Koch et al., 2009); however, others have documented that yields can be similar between the two tillage approaches (Van den Putte et al., 2010). To our knowledge, no studies have evaluated organic table beet performance in reduced-till systems.
The application of temporary, impermeable, black plastic tarps to the soil surface before cash crop planting is an alternative weed management strategy recently popularized (Fortier, 2014), and adopted by some organic vegetable farmers (Rylander and Raucher, 2019). Tarps are durable, opaque, 0.15-mm (5- to 6-mil) polyethylene plastic applied to multiple crop rows at a time. Farmers can apply and remove tarps multiple times in a season and use them for several years. This practice is in contrast to well-studied black plastic mulch films (Abu-Gharbieh et al., 1988), which remain in place during crop growth, and to solarization with temporary placement of transparent plastic sheets on the soil at times of intense sunlight and warm temperatures. Solarization can reduce weed pressure and increase yields in numerous crops (Candido et al., 2011; Egley, 1983; Kanaan et al., 2018; Khan et al., 2012; Linke, 1994; Samtani et al., 2017); to be effective, soil temperatures must reach 40 to 65 °C to kill weeds, weed seeds, and other pests (Abu-Gharbieh et al., 1988; Egley, 1983; Öz, 2018).
Tarps may reduce reliance on tillage by providing a number of similar services. Tarps applied for 3 weeks suppress weeds before crop planting and create a weed-free seedbed in which to plant (Birthisel, 2018; Lounsbury et al., 2018; Rylander et al., 2020). Tarps also have the potential to promote fatal germination of some weeds by blocking light from emerged seedlings, but this may depend on other management factors, including the duration and timing of tarp use and soil disturbance before tarp application. The effect of tarps on weed seeds is also likely species specific. Although tarps have shown no effect on Chenopodium album L. seed germination and degradation, survival of Amaranthus powellii S. Wats. seeds in the top 1 cm of soil can be higher under tarped compared with untarped soil, indicating a lower germination and degradation rate under tarps (Rylander et al., 2020).
Earlier results from this experiment, presented in Rylander et al. (2020), found tarping can create a soil environment favorable for crop planting by increasing soil moisture, temperature, and soil nitrate, while decreasing weeds by 95% to 100% at planting time without soil disturbance. Three weeks of tarp duration was adequate to achieve differences compared with untarped controls. The following research investigated the effect of black plastic tarp durations on weeds and yields of a direct-seeded beet crop and compared three levels of tillage intensity after tarp removal. We hypothesized that 1) tarping would lower weed density and biomass during beet crop growth, 2) tarping would increase beet crop yield, 3) differences in tarped and untarped soils would be greatest within no-till systems, and 4) longer tarp durations would have a greater effect on these responses.
Abu-Gharbieh, W.I., Saleh, H. & Abu-Blan, H. 1988 Use of black plastic for soil solarization and post-plant mulching. FAO Plant Production and Protection Paper 109. Plant Protection Dept., Faculty of Agr., Univ. of Jordan, Amman, Jordan
Arshad, M.A., Franzluebbers, A.J. & Azooz, R.H. 1999 Components of surface soil structure under conventional and no-tillage in northwestern Canada Soil Tillage Res. 53 41 47
Beare, M.H., Hu, S., Coleman, D.C. & Hendrix, P.F. 1997 Influences of mycelial fungi on soil aggregation and organic matter storage in conventional and no-tillage soils Appl. Soil Ecol. 5 3 826 831
Benech-Arnold, R.L., Sa Ânchez, R.A., Forcella, F., Kruk, B.C. & Ghersa, C.M. 2000 Environmental control of dormancy in weed seed banks in soil Field Crops Res. 67 105 122
Birthisel, S.K. 2018 Multi-tactic ecological weed management in a changing climate. Univ. of Maine, Orono, PhD Diss. 2928
Buhler, D.D., Stoltenberg, D.E. & Becker, R.L. 1994 Perennial weed populations after 14 years of variable tillage and cropping practices Weed Sci. 42 205 209
Campiglia, E., Radicetti, E. & Mancinelli, R. 2018 Floristic composition and species diversity of weed community after 10 years of different cropping systems and soil tillage in a Mediterranean environment Weed Res. 58 273 283
Candido, V., Castronuovo, D., Miccolis, V. & D’Addabbo, T. 2011 Weed control and yield response of soil solarization with different plastic films in lettuce Scientia Hort. 130 491 497
Cavalaris, C.K. & Gemtos, T.A. 2002 Evaluation of four conservation tillage methods in the sugar beet crop CIGR J. Sci. Res. Dev. 4 1 24
Fortier, J.-M. 2014 The market gardener: A successful grower’s handbook for small-scale organic farming. New Society Publishers, Gabriola Island, BC, Canada
Franzluebbers, A.J. 2002 Water infiltration and soil structure related to organic matter and its stratification with depth Soil Tillage Res. 66 197 205
Gupta, V.V.S.R. & Germida, J.J. 1988 Distribution of microbial biomass and its activity in different soil aggregate size classes as affected by cultivation Soil Biol. Biochem. 20 6 826 831
Halde, C., Bamford, K.C. & Entz, M.H. 2015 crop agronomic performance under a six-year continuous organic no-till system and other tilled and conventionally-managed systems in the Northern Great Plains of Canada Agr. Ecosyst. Environ. 213 121 130
Hungria, M., Franchini, J.C., Brandão-Junior, O., Kaschuk, G. & Souza, R.A. 2009 Soil microbial activity and crop sustainability in a long-term experiment with three soil-tillage and two crop-rotation systems Appl. Soil Ecol. 42 3 826 831
Kanaan, H., Frenk, S., Raviv, M., Medina, S. & Minz, D. 2018 Long and short term effects of solarization on soil microbiome and agricultural production Appl. Soil Ecol. 124 54 61
Khan, M.A., Khan, R., Khan, H., Shah, H.U., Marwat, K.B., Amin, A. & Nawaz, A. 2012 Soil solarization: An organic weed-management approach in cauliflower Commun. Soil Sci. Plant Anal. 43 13 826 831
Koch, H.-J., Märländer, B., Büchse, A. & Dieckmann, J. 2009 Yield decrease in sugar beet caused by reduced tillage and direct drilling Eur. J. Agron. 30 2 826 831
Leavitt, M.J., Sheaffer, C.C., Wyse, D.L. & Allan, D.L. 2011 Rolled winter rye and hairy vetch cover crops lower weed density but reduce vegetable yields in no-tillage organic production HortScience 46 387 395
Linke, K.H. 1994 Effects of soil solarization on arable weeds under Mediterranean conditions: Control, lack of response or stimulation Crop Prot. 13 2 826 831
Lounsbury, N.P., Warren, N.D., Wolfe, S.D. & Smith, R.G. 2018 Investigating tarps to facilitate organic no-till cabbage production with high-residue cover crops. Renewable Ag. Food Systems. p. 1–7
Lowry, C.J. & Brainard, D.C. 2017 Organic farmer perceptions of reduced tillage: A Michigan farmer survey Renew. Agr. Food Syst. 34 2 826 831
Nakamoto, T., Yamagishi, J. & Miura, F. 2006 Effect of reduced tillage on weeds and soil organisms in winter wheat and summer maize cropping on humic andosols in central Japan Soil Tillage Res. 85 1-2 826 831
Mendoza, R.B., Franti, T.G., Doran, J.W., Powers, T.O. & Zanner, C.W. 2008 Tillage effects on soil quality indicators and nematode abundance in loessial soil under long-term no-till production Commun. Soil Sci. Plant Anal. 39 2169 2190
Öz, H. 2018 A new approach to soil solarization: Addition of biochar to the effect of soil temperature and quality and yield parameters of lettuce (Lactuca sativa L. Duna) Scientia Hort. 228 153 161
Power, J.F., Wilhelm, W.W. & Doran, J.W. 1986 Crop residue effects on soil environment and dryland maize and soya bean production Soil Tillage Res. 8 101 111
R Core Team 2017 R: A language and environment for statistical computing. R Foundation for Statistical Computing, Vienna, Austria. <https://R-project.org/>
Rylander, H.R., Rangarajan, A., Maher, R.M., Hutton, M.G., Rowley, N.W., McGrath, M.T. & Sexton, Z.F. 2020 Black plastic tarps advance organic reduced tillage I: Impacts on soils, weed seed survival, and crop residue. HortScience 55 819 825
Samtani, J.B., Derr, J., Conway, M.A. & Flanagan, R.D. III 2017 Evaluating soil solarization for weed control and strawberry (Fragaria xananassa) yield in annual plasticulture production Weed Technol. 31 455 463
Tebrügge, F. & Düring, R.-A. 1999 Reducing tillage intensity: A review of results from a long-term study in Germany Soil Tillage Res. 53 15 28
Van den Putte, A., Govers, G., Diels, J., Gillijns, K. & Demuzere, M. 2010 Assessing the effect of soil tillage on crop growth: A meta-regression analysis on European crop yields under conservation agriculture Eur. J. Agron. 33 231 241