Pollination deficits and subsequent low fruit set remain among the most important horticultural challenges to sustained yields of highbush blueberry in northwestern Washington (Washington Blueberry Commission, 2017). Washington State is a part of the Pacific Northwest (PNW), which is a major blueberry production region, contributing significantly to global production of both conventional and organic highbush blueberry. In 2016, Washington State was the nation’s leading producer of blueberries with over 54.4 million kg of berries harvested from 5423 ha and a production value of about $94 million (USDA, 2016). Blueberry growers in the PNW frequently apply Ca and B foliarly as annual applications for field maintenance and promotion of fruit set and crop yields. This practice is often done regardless of plant nutrient status and despite a lack of evidence supporting their regular use for this specific purpose. The goal of this project was to evaluate the impact of foliar applications of Ca and B and assess whether these practices should be recommended to promote fruit set and subsequent yields in highbush blueberry grown in the PNW.
Pollination and ovule fertilization in highbush blueberry normally occurs over a 5- to 12-d period on a per flower basis (Dogterom et al., 2000). Pollination may be constrained in this short time-period because of marginal weather conditions that reduce honeybee (Apis mellifera L.) activity (i.e., air temperature <12 °C, wind speed >20 kph) and nutrient deficiencies (Tuell and Isaacs, 2010). Reproductive tissues (i.e., pollen, ovules, and developing embryos) are sensitive to nutrient concentrations in the flower and stem tissues (May and Killingbeck, 1992). Increased availability of nutrients involved in pollen tube elongation, plasma-membrane functioning, and other reproductive processes critical for fertilization and berry development, specifically Ca and B, could potentially increase fruit set under conditions that are otherwise limiting (Kumar et al., 2016; Muengkaew et al., 2017).
Blueberry plants are calcifuges, requiring low soil pH and having generally efficient uptake of Ca relative to other temperate fruit crops (Taiz and Zeiger, 2002). Calcium movement and distribution within the blueberry plant varies by cultivar (Strik and Vance, 2015). Despite sufficient leaf Ca concentrations (0.41% to 0.8% Ca; Hart et al., 2006), limited movement of Ca from leaf and stem tissues into developing reproductive tissues may lead to deficiencies, reducing fruit quality and, in some cultivars (e.g., ‘Draper’), causing poor fruit development and premature fruit drop (Gerbrandt, 2015). Calcium mobility is often limited due to relatively low rates of fruit transpiration (2.5–3.0 mmol CO2/kg/h) compared with leaves, thereby limiting the movement of dissolved Ca in the xylem to fruit (Angeletti et al., 2010).
Calcium (Ca) is involved in fruit abscission and pollen tube growth (Brewbaker and Kwack, 1963; Malho and Trewavas, 1996). Calcium deficiency can reduce the strength of the middle lamella and consequently make cells more prone to shearing, leading to fruit abscission (Glenn et al., 1988; Gough and Litke, 1980). Low Ca concentrations in the pollen of primrose (Primula officinalis L.) and butcher’s broom (Ruscus aculeatus L.) have been correlated with reduced rates of pollen germination, with some dependence of germination on Ca levels found within the stigma (Bednarska, 1991; Brewbaker and Kwack, 1963; Taylor and Hepler, 1997). Calcium concentrations in the stigma and style may similarly impact the effectiveness of pollen germination and tube elongation, as suggested in studies in tobacco (Nicotinia tabacum L.) and Japanese pear (Pyrus pyrifolia L.) (Ge et al., 2009; Hiratsuka et al., 2002). To improve pollen viability and fruit set, Ca is often applied alone or mixed with other foliar-applied agrochemicals during bloom and throughout the growing season in highbush blueberry grown in the PNW. Growers also apply foliar Ca because preharvest applications may increase fruit firmness, an important attribute of quality for fresh fruit (Angeletti et al., 2010). Calcium is rarely soil applied in blueberry, in part because it has been shown to inconsistently affect leaf and fruit Ca levels and has had no effect on berry yield, size, or firmness based on studies conducted in Michigan (Hanson and Berkheimer, 2004). However, there is risk when applying commercial Ca-containing foliar fertilizers, specifically for formulations that contain calcium chloride. High rates of calcium chloride can cause leaf phytotoxicity because of blueberry’s sensitivity to the chloride ion, especially in young blueberry plants (Retamales and Arredondo, 1995).
Boron (B) is an important micronutrient for plant growth. In blueberries, B may be especially important for pollen germination and cell elongation (Retamales and Hancock, 2012). Boron is often deficient in blueberry production in western Washington and Oregon, and this is exacerbated by dry weather and heavy crop loads (Marshner, 1995). Boron in the soil reaches plant roots largely through mass flow; deficiency is common in soils with low organic matter, sandy/coarse texture, or both (Goldberg, 1997). The difference between sufficiency and toxicity of B is marginal in plants, including blueberry. Typically, B is not applied at concentrations higher than 500 ppm in blueberry because of the risk of phytotoxicity (Hart et al., 2006). Although B is readily absorbed and mobile within the xylem of plants, making foliar applications during the dynamic growth phase, occurring during floral development, pollen germination, fertilization, and early berry development, may increase absorption and movement to targeted tissues (Brown and Hu, 1996; Lord and Russell, 2002). This intense period of development is metabolically demanding, and plant nutrient levels at this stage may have far-reaching consequences on fruit set, berry weight, yield, and fruit composition at harvest to various degrees across cultivars. Annual applications of B are recommended in blueberry based on tissue nutrient analyses, but the justification and impact of these applications on promoting fruit set is largely unknown in the PNW region (Hart et al., 2006).
The application of Ca and B as foliar nutrients in early spring may improve pollen health and ovule fertilization, as well as fruit set, berry development, and subsequent berry yields. It is hypothesized that application of these nutrients during the dynamic growth stages of flower and fruit development, when these nutrients may be limiting, will be most effective at enhancing these variables associated with yield. Therefore, a trial was conducted with the objective to investigate whether foliar Ca and B applied from early pink bud to petal fall would increase fruit set, yield, and attributes of berry quality (size and firmness) in highbush blueberry grown in northwest Washington.
AngelettiP.CastagnassoH.MiceliE.TerminielloL.ConcellónA.ChavesA.VicenteA.2010Effect of preharvest calcium applications on postharvest quality, softening and cell wall degradation of two blueberry (Vaccinium corymbosum) varietiesPostharvest Biol. Technol.5898103
BednarskaE.1991Calcium uptake from the stigma by germinating pollen in Primula officinalis L. and Ruscus aculeatus LSex. Plant Reprod.43638
BrownP.HuH.1996Phloem mobility of boron is species dependent: Evidence for phloem mobility in sorbitol-rich speciesAnn. Bot. (Lond.)77497506
ChangY.C.Grace-MartinK.MillerW.B.2004Efficacy of exogenous calcium application for reducing upper leaf necrosis in Lilium ‘Star Gazer’HortScience39272275
CheourF.WillemontC.ArulJ.DesjardinsY.MakhloufJ.CharestP.M.GosselinA.1990Foliar application of calcium chloride delays postharvest ripening of strawberryJ. Amer. Soc. Hort. Sci.115789792
CourcellesD.M.M.ButtonL.ElleE.2013Bee visit rates vary with floral morphology among highbush blueberry cultivars (Vaccinium corymbosum L.)J. Appl. Entomol.137693701
DeVetterL.W.WatkinsonS.SagiliR.LawrenceT.2016Honey bee activity in northern highbush blueberry differs across growing regions in Washington stateHortScience5112281232
DogteromM.H.WinstonM.L.MukaiA.2000Effect of pollen load size and source (self, outcross) on seed and fruit production in highbush blueberry cv. ‘Bluecrop’ (Vaccinium corymbosum; Ericaceae)Amer. J. Bot.8715841591
EhlenfeldtM.K.MartinR.B.2002A survey of fruit firmness in highbush blueberry and species-introgressed blueberry cultivarsHortScience37386389
GavlakR.HorneckD.MillerR.O.Kotuby-AmacherJ.2003Soil, plant and water reference methods for the western region. WCC-103 publicationWREP1251736
GeL.L.XieC.T.TianH.Q.RussellS.D.2009Distribution of calcium in the stigma and style of tobacco during pollen germination and tube elongationSex. Plant Reprod.228796
GerbrandtE.2015What causes green fruit drop and can we prevent it? Horticulture Growers’ Short Course. Lower Mainland Hort. Improvement Assn. Pacific Ag. Show Proc. 57th
GlennG.M.ReddyA.S.N.PoovaiahB.W.1988Effect of calcium on cell wall structure, protein phosphorylation and protein profile in senescing applesPlant Cell Physiol.29565572
HartJ.M.StrikB.WhiteL.YangW.2006Nutrient management for blueberries in Oregon. Oregon State University Extension Service. EM 8918
HendersonH.VealP.1948The effect of the interrelationship of boron and manganese on the growth and calcium uptake of blue lupine (Lupinus angustifolius L.) in solution culturePlant Physiol.23609620
HiratsukaS.WatanabeM.KawaiY.MaejimaT.KawamuraK.KatohY.2002Action mode of calcium formate as a chemical thinner on Japanese pear flowerJ. Jpn. Soc. Hort. Sci.716267
KumarJ.KumarR.RaiR.Shankar MishraD.Kumar SinghS.Kisan NimbolkarP.2016Influence of foliar application of mineral nutrients at different growth stages of guavaJ. Plant Nutr.40656661
MarshnerH.1995Mineral nutrition of higher plants. Academic Press New York NY
de MendiburuF.2014Statistical procedures for agricultural research. National Engineering University Lima Peru MS Thesis
Michigan State University Extension (MSU Extension)2016Blueberry growth stages table. 2 Feb. 2017. <http://msue.anr.msu.edu/topic/blueberries/growing_blueberries/growth_stages_table>
MorrisJ.R.CawthonD.L.NelsonG.S.CooperP.E.1980Effects of postharvest calcium sprays and postharvest holding on firmness and quality of machine-harvested blackberriesHortScience153334
MuengkaewR.ChaiprasartP.WongsawadP.2017Calcium-boron addition promotes pollen germination and fruit set of mangoIntl. J. Fruit Sci.17147158
RetamalesJ.B.ArredondoC.A.1995Calcium and fruit firmness in highbush blueberry: Natural gradients and the effect of foliar applicationsHortScience30784
RetamalesJ.B.HancockJ.F.2012Blueberries. Vol. 21. Cabi New York NY
RStudio Team2015RStudio: Integrated development for R. RStudio Inc. Boston MA. <http://www.rstudio.com>
SaftnerR.PolashockJ.EhlenfeldtM.VinyardB.2008Instrumental and sensory quality characteristics of blueberry fruit from twelve cultivarsPostharvest Biol. Technol.491926
SchlegelK.SchönherrJ.2001Selective permeability of cuticles over stomata and trichomes to calcium chlorideIntl. Symp. Foliar Nutr. Perennial Fruit Plants5949196
SeeleyT.D.2009The wisdom of the hive: The social physiology of honey bee colonies. Harvard Univ. Press Boston MA
StrikB.C.VanceA.J.2015Seasonal variation in leaf nutrient concentration of northern highbush blueberry cultivars grown in conventional and organic production systemsHortScience5014531466
StrikB.BrunC.AhmedullahM.AntonelliA.AskhamL.BarneyD.HavensD.1993Highbush blueberry production. PNW 215 (USA)
TaizL.ZeigerE.2002Plant physiology. 5th ed. Sinauer Associates Sunderland MA
United States Department of Agriculture (USDA)2016Noncitrus fruits and nuts 2016 summary. 27 June 2017. <http://usda.mannlib.cornell.edu/usda/nass/NoncFruiNu//2010s/2016/NoncFruiNu-07-27-2016.pdf>
United States Department of Agriculture (USDA)2017Web soil survey. 10 Jan. 2017. http://websoilsurvey.nrcs.usda.gov/
VanceA.J.JonesP.StrikB.C.2017Foliar calcium applications do not improve quality or shelf life of strawberry, raspberry, blackberry, or blueberry fruitHortScience52382387
Washington Blueberry Commission20172 Feb. 2017. <http://wablueberrycomm.org/>
Washington State University (WSU) AgWeatherNet2017Historical weather data. 2 Feb. 2017. <http://weather.wsu.edu>
WickhamH.2009‘ggplot2’: Elegant graphics for data analysis. Springer New York NY