Hard cider is an alcoholic beverage produced from fermented apple juice or apple juice concentrate. Domestic cider consumption has increased more than 850% in the last 5 years and there are now over 550 cider producers in the United States (TTB, 2007–14; Brown, 2016). The vast majority of cider produced in the United States is made from apple cultivars that were originally planted for fresh or processing markets (Peck and Miles, 2015). Culinary apples do not have all of the fruit quality characteristics desired by cider producers, but many of the desired cider apple cultivars have not been documented as being widely planted in the United States (Miles et al., 2015; Peck, 2012; U.S. Apple Association, 2015). In the United States, where the production of traditional hard cider apple cultivars has lagged behind the increase in cider sales, methods to increase cider quality from existing apple cultivars are needed.
Fruit quality attributes that are important for culinary apple production include low incidence of damage and decay, fruit shape and size (typically measured by fruit mass), peel color, flesh firmness, soluble solid concentration (SSC), titratable acidity (TA) and pH, and flavor (La Belle, 1981). Along with the starch pattern index (SPI) and internal ethylene concentration (IEC), fruit quality factors are often measured to gauge harvest maturity (Watkins, 2003). For cider production, fruit quality attributes also include polyphenol and YAN concentrations in the fruit, and juice yield, while cosmetic attributes such as color, shape, and size are much less important (Lea, 1996).
Apple orchard management practices that focus on fruit quality characteristics that are desirable for cider production are needed. Specifically, most apples commercially grown in the United States have low YAN and polyphenol concentrations (Thompson-Witrick et al., 2014). While both exogenous nitrogen and polyphenols (i.e., “enological tannins”) may be added to increase their concentration in cider, the sensory impact of addition of these products to cider warrants further investigation. For example, the addition of commercially available exogenous tannins to red wine has been shown to increase the measured total polyphenol concentration, but they did not always lead to improvement in sensory character (Harbertson et al., 2012). As such, increasing endogenous polyphenol concentration in fruit remains the generally preferred approach to achieve desired sensory characteristics for wine and cider.
In European wine grape (Vitis vinifera L.) production, measurable improvements in fruit quality have been achieved through adjusting the relationship between fruit yield and vegetative growth, often referred to as crop load. Grape cluster crop load has been shown to impact secondary metabolism in grape berries, which can in turn impact wine chemistry, aroma, and flavor. For example, SSC was greater in ‘Chambourcin’ grapes that were from vines with reduced fruit clusters (Dami et al., 2006). Similarly, lower crop loads for ‘Sauvignon blanc’ grapevines resulted in wine that had more favorable sensory scores (Naor et al., 2002). A study of ‘Shiraz’ grapevines under five training systems in the Barossa Valley of Australia demonstrated that grape berry anthocyanin and polyphenol concentrations decreased with increasing crop load (Wolf et al., 2003). However, a point is reached when continuing to decrease crop load results in decreased yield and increased production cost, but no further increase in wine quality (Berkey et al., 2011; Bravdo et al., 1985; Preszler et al., 2010). Although horticultural practices for apples and grapes are quite different, wine grape growers exert a tremendous amount of effort optimizing fruit quality to make their crop more desirable to their buyers. For these reasons, crop load targets are often specified in vineyard management with the goal of maintaining optimal fruit quality for winemaking (Wolf, 2008).
With the increased utilization of apples for cider production, it is necessary to more fully understand how orchard management decisions, such as crop load density, impact cider quality. The development of crop load management practices can be used by orchard managers to improve cider produced from culinary apples. The goal of this project was to assess the impact of three different crop load densities on fruit and cider quality.
Alcohol and Tobacco Tax and Trade Bureau, Department of the Treasury (TTB). 2007–14. Statistical Report – Wine. 20 Aug 2016. <https://www.ttb.gov/wine/wine-stats.shtml>
Alonso-Salces, R.M., Herrero, C., Barranco, A., Berrueta, L.A., Gallo, B. & Vicente, F. 2005 Classification of apple fruits according to the maturity state by the pattern recognition analysis of their polyphenol compositions Food Chem. 93 113 123
Awad, M.A., de Jager, A., Dekker, M. & Jongen, W.M.F. 2001 Formation of flavonoids and chlorogenic acid in apples as affected by crop load Scientia Hort. 91 227 237
Berkey, T.G., Mansfield, A.K., Lerch, S.D., Meyers, J.M. & Vanden Heuvel, J.E. 2011 Crop load adjustment in ‘Seyval blanc’ winegrape: Impacts on yield components, fruit composition, consumer wine preferences, and economics of production HortTechnology 21 593 598
Blanpied, G.D. & Silsby, K.J. 1992 Predicting harvest date windows for apples. Cornell Coop. Ext. Publ. Info. Bull. 221
Bohlscheid, J.C., Osborne, J.P., Ross, C.F. & Edwards, C.G. 2011 Interactive effects of selected nutrients and fermentation temperature on H2S production by wine strains of Saccharomyces J. Food Qual. 34 51 55
Bravdo, B., Hepner, Y., Loinger, C., Cohen, S. & Tabacman, H. 1985 Effect of crop level and crop load on growth, yield, must and wine composition, and quality of Cabernet sauvignon Amer. J. Enol. Viticult. 36 2 125 131
Brown, D. 2016 Cider maker survey: Current USA cider makers survey—updated Dec. 2015. 20 Aug. 2016. <https://www.cydermarket.com/cider-maker-survey.html>.
Byers, R. & Carbaugh, D. 2002 Effects of thinning time and yield, fruit size, and return bloom of ‘York’ and ‘Golden Delicious’ apple trees J. Tree Fruit Prod. 3 1 55 62
Dami, I., Ferree, D., Prajitna, A. & Surlock, D. 2006 A five-year study on the effect of cluster thinning on yield and fruit composition of ‘Chambourcin’ grapevines HortScience 41 586 588
De Salvador, F.R., Fisichella, M. & Fontanari, M. 2006 Correlations between fruit size and fruit quality in apple trees with high and standard crop load levels J. Fruit Ornamental Plant Res. 14 Suppl. 2 113 122
Embree, C.G., Myra, M.T.D., Nichols, D.S. & Wright, A.H. 2007 Effect of bloom density, and crop load on growth, fruit quality, and return bloom in ‘Honeycrisp’ apple HortScience 42 1622 1625
Harbertson, J.F., Parpinello, G.P., Heymann, H. & Downey, M.O. 2012 Impact of exogenous tannin additions on wine chemistry and wine sensory character Food Chem. 131 3 999 1008
La Belle, R.L. 1981 Apple quality characteristics as related to various processed products, p. 61–76. In: R. Teranishi and H. Barrera-Benetiz (eds.). Quality of selected fruits and vegetables in North America. Amer. Chem. Soc., Geneva, NY.
Lea, A.G.H. 1996 Cidermaking. In: A.G.H. Lea and J.R. Piggott (eds.). Fermented beverage production. Blackie and Sons, Glasgow, Scotland
Marini, R.P., Barden, J.A., Cline, J.A., Perry, R. & Robinson, T. 2002 Effect of apple rootstocks on average ‘Gala’ fruit weight at four locations after adjusting for crop load J. Amer. Soc. Hort. Sci. 127 749 753
Mendes-Ferreira, A., Mendes-Faia, A. & Leão, C. 2004 Growth and fermentation patterns of Saccharomyces cerevisiae under different ammonium concentrations and its implications in winemaking industry J. Appl. Microbiol. 97 540 545
Miles, C., King, J. & Peck, G. 2015 Commonly grown cider apple cultivars in the U.S. WSU Cider Report 202. WSU NWREC, Mount Vernon, WA
Naor, A., Gal, Y. & Bravdo, B. 2002 Shoot and cluster thinning influence vegetative growth, fruit yield, and wine quality of ‘Sauvignon blanc’ grapevines J. Amer. Soc. Hort. Sci. 127 628 634
Peck, G.M., Andrews, P.K., Reganold, J.P. & Fellman, J.K. 2006 Apple orchard productivity and fruit quality under organic, conventional, and integrated management HortScience 41 99 107
Peck, G. 2012 Hard cider production in Virginia. 20 Aug. 2016. <http://www.arec.vaes.vt.edu/alson-h-smith/treefruit/horticulture/hard-cider/>.
Peck, G.M. & Miles, C. 2015 Assessing the production scale and research and extension needs of U.S. hard cider producers J. Ext. 53 5 FEA10
Pfeiffer, D.G., Bergh, J.C., Fell, R.D., Hooks, C.R.R., Peck, G.M., Walsh, C.S., Yoder, K.S., Biggs, A.R., Kotcon, J.B., Derr, J.F., Chandran, R.S., Weaver, M.J., Brown, A. & Parkhurst, J. 2014 Spray bulletin for commercial tree fruit growers. VA. Coop. Ext. Publ. 456–419
Preszler, T., Schmit, T.M. & Vanden Heuvel, J.E. 2010 A model to establish economically sustainable cluster-thinning practices Amer. J. Enol. Viticult. 61 1 140 146
Renard, C.M.G.G., Dupont, N. & Guillermin, P. 2007 Concentrations and characteristics of procyanidins and other phenolics in apples during fruit growth Phytochemistry 68 1128 1138
Renard, C.M.G.C., LeQuéré, J.-M., Bauduin, R., Symoneaux, R., LeBourvellec, C. & Baron, A. 2011 Modulating polyphenolic composition and organoleptic properties of apple juices by manipulating the pressing conditions Food Chem. 124 117 125
Serra, S., Leisso, R., Giodani, L., Kalcsits, L. & Musacchi, S. 2016 Crop load influences fruit quality, nutritional balance, and return bloom in ‘Honeycrisp’ apple HortScience 51 236 244
Stopar, M., Bolcina, U., Vanzo, A. & Vrhovsek, U. 2002 Lower crop load for cv. Jonagold apples (Malus × domestica Borkh.) increases polyphenol content and fruit quality J. Agr. Food Chem. 50 6 1643 1646
Thompson-Witrick, K.A., Goodrich, K.M., Neilson, A.P., Hurley, E.K., Peck, G.M. & Stewart, A.S. 2014 Characterization of the polyphenol composition of 20 cultivars of cider, processing, and dessert apples (Malus × domestica Borkh.) grown in Virginia J. Agr. Food Chem. 62 10181 10191
Unuk, T., Tojnko, S., Cmelik, Z. & Stopar, M. 2006 Polyphenol content in apple fruits as affected by crop load and rate of applied nitrogen Acta Hort. 721 173 176
U.S. Apple Association 2015 The production and utilization analysis for 2015. U.S. Apple Association, Vienna, VA
Waterhouse, A.L. 2002 Determination of total phenolics. In: Current protocols in food analytical chemistry. DOI: 10.1002/0471142913.faa0101s06
Watkins, C.B. 2003 Principles and practices of postharvest handling and stress, p. 237–266. In: D.C. Ferree and I.J. Warrington (eds.). Apples: Botany, production, and uses. CABI, Wallingford, Oxon, UK.
Wolf, T.K. 2008 Crop yield estimation and crop management, p. 135–140. In: T.K. Wolf (ed.). Wine grape production guide for Eastern North America. Natural Resource Agr. Eng. Serv. NRAES-145. Ithaca, NY
Wolf, T.K., Dry, P.R., Iland, P.G., Botting, D., Dick, J., Kennedy, U. & Ristic, R. 2003 Response of Shiraz grapevines to five different training systems in the Barossa Valley, Australia Austral. J. Grape Wine Res. 9 82 95
Wünshe, J.M., Greer, D.H., Laing, W.A. & Palmer, J.W. 2005 Physiological and biochemical leaf and tree responses to crop load in apple Tree Physiol. 25 1253 1263