The growing interest in sustainable local food production has created incentives for crop producers, especially in urban areas, to grow food for local consumption using low-cost, renewable materials and/or organic production techniques (Butler and Maronek, 2002; Lorenz and Lal, 2009; McCullum et al., 2005; Organic Trade Association, 2011). Alternative, low-cost weed management strategies are appealing in urban environments because of the close proximity of crop production to people, which may preclude the use of pesticides, or the use of mechanical tillage because of a lack of space or financial resources for equipment and skilled labor. The recycling of urban wastes such as paper and plant trimmings for weed suppression in urban farms could potentially represent an inexpensive and renewable alternative to herbicides, tillage, and hand weeding.
Beginning with their commercial introduction in the 1960s, plastic film mulches coupled with drip irrigation have played a major role in increasing yields of several vegetable crops (Kasirajan and Ngouajio, 2012). Black polyethylene plastic conserves soil moisture and is impervious to light and rainfall, making it effective at controlling weeds but conducive to excessive water runoff (Feeser et al., 2014). Polyethylene mulch in tomato plots resulted in two to four times more water runoff and six to 19 times more pesticide runoff than plots mulched with hairy vetch (Vicia villosa) residues (Rice et al., 2001). Black plastic mulch can also cause heat stress in some crops during hot weather (Gruda, 2008). Another major disadvantage of using nonbiodegradable polyethylene plastic mulches is that they require annual removal and proper disposal (Díaz-Pérez and Batal, 2002). Using black plastic mulch costs U.S. vegetable growers up to $750/ha every year, which generates 112–135 kg·ha−1 waste plastic with an added disposal cost of ≈$50/ha (Feeser et al., 2014).
Various biodegradable materials, including starch or cellulose-based bioplastic films and biofabrics, have been tested as alternatives to plastic mulch with varying results depending on crop, mulch material, and environmental factors (Kasirajan and Ngouajio, 2012; Miles et al., 2012; Wortman et al., 2015). Newspaper mulch is an alternative to nonbiodegradable plastic, but it can be prone to fragmentation on the soil surface and degrade too rapidly to provide a sufficient period of weed suppression (Schonbeck, 1999; Shogren, 2000). Several researchers have investigated that paper treated or mixed with various substances intended to delay biodegradation and/or enhance weed suppression, but results have been variable (Anderson et al., 1995; Shogren, 2000; Shogren and David, 2006).
An important factor affecting the efficacy of newspaper-based mulches for weed suppression is the fragment size of the paper when applied (e.g., shredded vs. sheets), and several studies have demonstrated that shredded newspaper mulches suppressed weeds and resulted in crop yields comparable to those provided by black plastic mulch (Grassbaugh et al., 2004; Laurie et al., 2014; Pellet and Heleba, 1995) or a hand-weeded control with no mulch (Sanchez et al., 2008). In a study where shredded newspaper was applied at a thickness of 10 or 15 cm, weed germination was suppressed for two seasons without any negative effect on two of the three nursery crops studied (Pellett and Heleba, 1995). Shredded newspaper provided comparable weed suppression to black plastic in tomato (Grassbaugh et al., 2004), and increased yields of sweet corn, soybeans, and tomato were achieved using shredded paper mulch compared with straw mulch or bare ground (Munn, 1992). In contrast, ground newspaper mulch (particle size ≈0.1 cm2) resulted in collard yield lower than or equivalent to bare soil, and collard tissue nitrogen (N) concentration lower than under bare soil, black plastic, or wood chip mulch (Guertal and Edwards, 1996). Chopped newspaper (5 × 5 cm squares applied at a 7.6-cm thickness) controlled weeds in tomato more consistently than 12.7-cm-thick shredded newspaper (1 cm by 60 to 75 cm long strips) or 15.2-cm-thick wheat straw mulch, and also provided greater weed suppression than black plastic or plastic landscape fabric (Monks et al., 1997).
Recycled newsprint is a resource available in large quantities, especially in and around urban centers (Paper Industry Association Council, 2007). In the past, there was concern about the environmental impact of some newspaper inks that contained polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) of environmental and health concern; however, by the mid-1990s, most newspapers switched to soy-based ink that does not contain PAHs (Anderson et al., 1995). Application of newsprint as a mulch is acceptable under organic certification as long as the newsprint is not contaminated with glossy advertising pages or colored inks (USDA, 2008).
One challenge with using paper as a mulch material is soil N immobilization. Noncomposted, recycled paper products have a high C:N ratio (≈500:1) that upon decomposition can result in a depletion of plant-available soil N (Edwards, 1997; Glenn et al., 2000; Tahboub and Lindemann, 2007). Combining paper with plant residues having a lower C:N ratio can reduce immobilization of inorganic N in the soil. In addition to providing supplemental N, plant residues and other organic materials can increase soil organic carbon and improve soil structure and quality (Saroa and Lal, 2003). Plant residues used as mulch materials have included grass clippings, straw of various cereal grains, wood fiber chipped from downed trees, and municipal leaf waste (Duppong et al., 2004). However, biological residues vary widely in N content and bioavailability. Fresh grass clippings represent a plant residue that can be comparatively high in bioavailable N and a potential resource in urban environments (Fang et al., 2007).
Plant residue may be less effective than plastic film as mulch for weed control because it often does not maintain a continuous barrier, and some areas of the soil surface can be left exposed due to residue decomposition or displacement by wind or water. Shredded newspaper becomes cohesive after being wetted by rainfall or overhead irrigation, reducing potential gaps between fragments (Grassbaugh et al., 2004). Combining shredded newspaper with plant residues such as grass clippings may offset the loss in weed control caused by gaps between grass fragments while also offsetting the high C:N ratio of paper.
The objective of this study was to compare the effects of shredded newspaper, NP + grass, woodchips, black plastic, and bare soil on weeds, insects, soil moisture, and soil temperature in pumpkin production.
Anderson, D.F., Garisto, M., Bourrut, J., Schonbeck, M.W., Jaye, R., Wurzberger, A. & DeGregorio, R. 1995 Evaluation of a paper mulch made from recycled materials as an alternative to plastic film mulch for vegetables J. Sustain. Agr. 7 39 61
Brady, N.C. & Weil, R.R. 1999 The nature and properties of soils, p. 294–304. 12th ed. Prentice Hall, Saddle River, NJ
Bullied, W.J., Marginet, A. & Van Acker, R.C. 2003 Conventional- and conservation-tillage systems influence emergence periodicity of annual weed species in canola Weed Sci. 51 886 897
Butler L. & Maronek D.M. 2002 Urban and agricultural communities: Opportunities for common ground. Council for Agr. Sci. and Technol., Ames, IA
Cartwright, B., Palumbo, J.C. & Fargo, W.S. 1990 Influence of crop mulches and row covers on the population dynamics of the squash bug (Heteroptera: Coreidae) on summer squash J. Econ. Entomol. 83 1988 1993
Cirujeda, A., Aibar, J., Anzalone, A., Martín-Closas, L., Meco, R., Moreno, M., Pardo, A., Pelacho, A.M., Rojo, F., Royo-Esnal, A., Suso, M.L. & Zaragoza, C. 2012 Biodegradable mulch instead of polyethylene for weed control of processing tomato production Agron. Sustain. Dev. 32 889 897
Cranshaw, W., Bartolo, M. & Schweissing, F. 2001 Control of squash bug (Hemiptera: Coreidae) injury: Management manipulations at the base of pumpkin Southwestern Entomologist 26 147 150
Díaz-Pérez, J.C. & Batal, K.D. 2002 Colored plastic film mulches affect tomato growth and yield via changes in root-zone temperature J. Amer. Soc. Hort. Sci. 127 127 136
Duppong, L.M., Delate, K., Liebman, M., Horton, R., Romero, F., Kraus, G., Petrich, J. & Chowdbury, P.K. 2004 The effect of natural mulches on crop performance, weed suppression and biochemical constituents of catnip and St. John’s Wort Crop Sci. 44 861 869
Edwards, J.H. 1997 Composition and uses of uncomposted wastepaper and other organics, p. 163–184. In: J.E. Rechigl and H.C. MacKinnon (eds.). Agricultural uses of by-products and wastes. Amer. Chem. Soc., Washington, DC
Fang, S., Xie, B. & Zhang, H. 2007 Nitrogen dynamics and mineralization in degraded agricultural soil mulched with fresh grass Plant Soil 300 269 280
Feeser, J., Zinati, G. & Moyer, J. 2014 Beyond black plastic: Cover crops and organic no-till for vegetable production. Rodale Inst., Kutztown, PA
Gallagher, R.S. & Cardina, J. 1998 Phytochrome-mediated Amaranthus germination II: Development of very low fluence sensitivity Weed Sci. 46 53 58
Glenn, J.S., Gilliam, C.H., Edwards, J.H., Keever, G.J. & Knight, P.R. 2000 Recycled waste paper mulch reduces available container N J. Environ. Hort. 18 188 191
Grassbaugh, E.M., Regnier, E.E. & Bennett, M.A. 2004 Comparison of organic and inorganic mulches for heirloom tomato production Acta Hort. 638 171 176
Gruda, N. 2008 The effect of wood fiber mulch on water retention, soil temperature and growth of vegetable plants J. Sustain. Agr. 32 629 643
Ham, J.M., Kluitenberg, G.J. & Lamont, W.J. 1993 Optical properties of plastic mulches affect the field temperature regime J. Amer. Soc. Hort. Sci. 118 188 193
Kasirajan, S. & Ngouajio, M. 2012 Polyethylene and biodegradable mulches for agricultural applications: A review Agron. Sustain. Dev. 32 501 529
Laurie, S.M., Maja, N.N., Ngobeni, H.M. & Du Plooy, C.P. 2014 Effect of different types of mulching and plant spacing on weed control, canopy cover and yield of sweet potato (Ipomoea batatas (L.) Lam) Amer. J. Exp. Agr. 5 450 458
Littell, R.C., Milliken, G.A., Stroup, W.W., Wolfinger, R.D. & Schabenberger, O. 2006 SAS for mixed models. 2nd ed. SAS Inst., Cary, NC
Littell, R.C., Stroup, W.W. & Freund, R.J. 2002 SAS for linear models. 4th ed. SAS Inst., Cary, NC
Loh, F.C.W., Grabosky, J.C. & Bassuk, N.L. 2002 Using the SPAD 502 meter to assess chlorophyll nitrogen content of Benjamin fig and cottonwood leaves HortTechnology 12 682 686
Marr, C., Schaplowsky, T. & Carey, T. 2004 Pumpkins: Commercial vegetable production. Kansas State Univ. Hort. Rpt. 10 Nov. 2015. <http://www.agmrc.org/media/cms/MF2030_0C42997F934A4.pdf>
McCullum, C., Desjardins, E., Kraak, V.I., Ladipo, P. & Costello, H. 2005 Evidence-based strategies to build community food security J. Amer. Dietetic Assn. 105 278 283
Miles, C., Wallace, R., Wszelaki, A., Martin, J., Cowan, J., Walters, T. & Inglis, D. 2012 Deterioration of potentially biodegradable alternatives to black plastic mulch in three tomato production regions HortScience 47 1270 1277
Monks, C.D., Monks, D.W., Basden, T., Selders, A., Poland, S. & Rayburn, E. 1997 Soil temperature, soil moisture, weed control, and tomato (Lypersicon esculentum) response to mulching Weed Technol. 11 561 566
Organic Trade Association 2011 U.S. organic industry overview. Organic Trade Association 2011 Organic Industry Survey. 17 Sept. 2015. <http://www.ota.com/pics/documents/2011OrganicIndustrySurvey.pdf>
Paper Industry Association Council 2007 American Forest and Paper Association Community Survey 2007. 5 June 2015. <http://www.paperrecycles.org/news/exec_summ.html>
Rice, P.J., McConnell, L.L., Heighton, L.P., Sadeghi, A.M., Isensee, A.R., Teasdale, J.R., Abdul-Baki, A.A., Harman-Fetcho, J.A. & Hapeman, C.J. 2001 Runoff loss of pesticides and soil: A comparison between vegetative mulch and plastic mulch in vegetable production systems J. Environ. Qual. 30 1808 1821
Sanchez, E., Lamont, W.J. Jr & Orzolek, M.D. 2008 Newspaper mulches for suppressing weeds for organic high-tunnel cucumber production HortTechnology 18 154 157
Saroa, G.S. & Lal, R. 2003 Soil restorative effects of mulching on aggregation and carbon sequestration in a Miamian soil in central Ohio Land Degrad. Dev. 14 481 493
Schafer, D.E. & Chilcote, D.O. 1970 Factors influencing persistence and depletion in buried seed populations. II. The effects of soil temperature and moisture Crop Sci. 10 342 345
Schonbeck, M.W. 1999 Weed suppression and labor costs associated with organic, plastic, and paper mulches in small-scale vegetable production J. Sustain. Agr. 13 13 33
Teasdale, J.R. & Mohler, C.L. 2000 The quantitative relationship between weed emergence and physical properties of mulches Weed Sci. 48 385 392
USDA (United States Depart. of Agr.) 2008 The national organic program: Program standards. 1 Oct. 2015. <http://www.ams.usda.gov/nop/NOP/standards.html>
Wortman, S.E., Kadoma, I. & Crandall, M.D. 2015 Assessing the potential for spunbond, nonwoven biodegradable fabric as mulches for tomato and bell pepper crops Scientia Hort. 193 209 217
Wyenandt, C.A., Riedel, R.M., Rhodes, L.H., Bennett, M.A. & Nameth, S.G.P. 2011 Fall- and spring-sown cover crop mulches affect yield, fruit cleanliness, and fusarium fruit rot development in pumpkin HortTechnology 21 343 354
Xiang, P. & Kuznetsov, A.V. 2008 Simulation of shape dynamics of a long flexible fiber in a turbulent flow in the hydroentanglement process Intl. Commun. Heat Mass Transf. 35 529 534