High tunnel use throughout the United States is on the increase as a result of earlier crop production and the opportunity to exploit local markets with regionally grown produce (Carey et al., 2009; Knewtson et al., 2010). In regions with short growing seasons, extending the production period can have significant economic benefit (Rader and Karlsson, 2006; Rowley et al., 2010; Waterer, 2003). Tomatoes (Solanum lycopersicum L.) are the most commonly grown high-tunnel crop because early, local, high-quality tomatoes have a high value in the market (Knewtson et al., 2010; Ward et al., 2011). Tomato is a common high-tunnel vegetable crop in Utah, and growers regularly ask if tunnels provide enough early protection when day–night temperatures vary significantly and, if so, when to plant. Producing tomatoes before outdoor field production begins extends revenue into a normally unproductive period and allows growers to benefit from out-of-season price premiums (Ward et al., 2011).
For climates near zone 5 on the USDA hardiness scale, growing in a high tunnel makes it possible to plant and produce tomatoes more than 1 month earlier than outdoors (Wells and Loy, 1993). By protecting plants from rainfall, high tunnels facilitate uniform watering, which is important for preventing disorders such as fruit cracking, blossom end rot, and many foliar diseases. High tunnels also provide more optimal temperatures for growth and improve quality by preventing disorders associated with poor pollination such as cat-facing and puffiness (Dorais et al., 2001). Krizek et al. (2006) showed that high tunnel-grown tomatoes had a higher sensory score for sweetness, flavor, texture, taste, and overall eating quality when compared with field-grown fruit.
The benefits of high-tunnel production have been explored in other states including Missouri, Connecticut, and New Jersey (Chism, 2002; Gent, 1992; Reiss et al., 2004), but research in arid high-elevation regions is lacking. In arid high-elevation climates like Utah, daytime temperatures spring can be quite warm (10 to 20 °C) even when nighttime temperatures are below freezing (Moller and Gillies, 2008). These extreme diurnal temperature variations can limit the length of the growing season for outdoor-grown vegetables. However, warm temperatures during the day and sunny skies could be used advantageously when high tunnels are incorporated into a farm’s production system. Utah gets more solar radiation on average than other parts of the United States that conduct high-tunnel tomato research. On average, the western United States receives 18–21.6 MJ·m−2·d−1 of solar radiation in April and 21.6–25.2 MJ·m−2·d−1 in May, whereas during the same period, regions of the central and eastern United States receive 14.4–18 and 18–21.6 MJ·m−2·d−1, respectively (Wilcox and Marion, 1994). Increased solar radiation should result in more accumulated heat units in a high tunnel compared with climates with more cloudy conditions. Arid climates also have the advantage of low relative humidity that should limit the development of problematic diseases common to more humid regions (Lamont, 2005; Wells and Loy, 1993).
In most of the Great Basin region (USDA hardiness zones 5a to 6b), tomatoes are typically transplanted outdoors in mid- to late May and begin to ripen in early August, whereas high-tunnel tomatoes can be planted 5 to 7 weeks earlier. Choosing an appropriate planting date is an important decision for growers in these climates. A 2-week delay in planting was shown to delay ripening by 2 weeks for early high-tunnel tomatoes transplanted in Connecticut (Gent, 1992). However, early-season cold weather makes planting risky during late March and early April even when grown in high tunnels. Row covers and low tunnels have been shown to provide some frost protection for early field-planted tomatoes (Ankara, 2001; Emmert, 1956; Waggoner, 1958) and could be used in combination with high tunnels.
Typical outdoor early spring temperatures (March and April) in northern Utah range from 10 to 20 °C during the day and –5 to 5 °C at night (Moller and Gillies, 2008). Day temperatures inside a high tunnel normally reach 20 to 30 °C, which is considered to be optimal for tomato (Kinet and Peet, 1997). However, nighttime temperatures in a high tunnel are typically only 1 to 4 °C warmer than the outside temperature, and consequently the high-tunnel environment is still susceptible to chilling or freezing conditions at night (Wien, 2009). Tomato plants are susceptible to chilling injury when exposed to temperatures below 10 °C (Kinet and Peet, 1997) and grow best when temperatures are 25 to 30 °C during the day and 16 to 20 °C at night (Csizinszky, 2005). Tomatoes are known to compensate growth when day or night temperatures are below optimum provided temperatures are optimal during the opposite period (Calvert, 1964).
The addition of rowcovers can increase temperatures 2 to 6 °C, and polyethylene rowcovers alone were shown to protect tomato plants from freezing when outside temperatures were –3.8 °C (Emmert, 1956; Waggoner, 1958). Low tunnels have also been shown to promote earlier tomato harvest and increase total yield within an unheated glasshouse, presumably by improving temperature conditions (Ankara, 2001). Waterer (2003) showed that heat unit accumulation, as measured by growing degree-days, was similar for low and high tunnels and both provided adequate plant protection when crops were planted in late May. However, this was after the risk of significant frost was passed. In New Jersey, polyester energy curtains placed inside a high tunnel were found to increase average night air temperatures 2.3 °C compared with the open field. In tunnels without curtains, temperatures were only 0.9 °C warmer than in the field (Both et al., 2007). In the arid, high-elevation regions of Utah, temperatures below –7 °C often occur from mid-March to late April when growers would be transplanting tomatoes into high tunnels (Moller and Gillies, 2008). These low temperatures may seriously limit early high-tunnel tomato production even when additional rowcovers are used. Therefore, targeted supplemental heat may aid in additional cold temperature protection during the early season.
Many high-tunnel production manuals advocate using protective structures like rowcovers and low tunnels inside high tunnels (Blomgren and Frisch, 2007; Byczynski, 2003; Lamont et al., 2005). However, few reports are available on the integration of supplemental heat additions and low tunnels within high tunnels. High tunnels typically do not use electricity; however, backup heating could provide the protection necessary to keep valuable plants alive in the early spring (Blomgren and Frisch, 2007). Supplemental heating is expensive, but costs may be reduced when used under low tunnels inside high tunnels, where heat would be concentrated around the plants. This approach has been used successfully for greenhouse tomatoes, where the amount of fuel needed to run the heating system was significantly reduced by targeting the heat at plant level using convection tubes (Hanna and Henderson, 2008). Soil warming has been shown to increase biomass accumulation and nutrient uptake for many crop greenhouse environments (Gosselin and Trudel, 1985; Hurewitz et al., 1984; Shedlosky and White, 1987). Although root zone heating can partly offset the adverse effect of low night air temperatures on greenhouse plants (Gosselin and Trudel, 1985; Janes and McAvoy, 1983), no published studies are known that assessed the effectiveness of root zone heating when high-tunnel air temperatures are near or below freezing.
The objectives of this project were to evaluate appropriate planting dates that provide early fruit production, to determine if low-cost supplemental heat sources can provide low-temperature protection for early-planted tomato, and to determine whether high-tunnel tomato production using these systems is economically viable.
Anderson, J.L., Richardson, E.A. & Kesner, C.D. 1986 Validation of chill unit and flower bud phenology models for ‘Montmorency’ sour cherry Acta Hort. 184 71 75
Ankara, L.A. 2001 Effect of low-tunnel, mulch and pruning on the yield and earliness of tomato in an unheated glasshouse J. Appl. Hort. 3 23 27
Black, B., Drost, D., Rowley, D. & Heflebower, R. 2008a Constructing a low-cost high tunnel. Utah State University Extension. 21 Dec. 2011. <http://extension.usu.edu/files/publications/publication/HG_High_Tunnels_2008-01photos.pdf>
Black, B., Frisby, J., Lewers, K., Takeda, F. & Finn, C. 2008b Heat unit model for predicting bloom dates in rubus HortScience 43 2000 2004
Blomgren, T. & Frisch, T. 2007 High tunnels: Using low-cost technology to increase yields, improve quality and extend the season. University of Vermont Center for Sustainable Agriculture, Burlington, VT. 21 Dec. 2011. <http://www.uvm.edu/sustainableagriculture/hightunnels.html>
Both, A.J., Reiss, E., Sudal, J.F., Holmstrom, K.E., Wyenandt, C.A., Kline, W.L. & Garrison, S.A. 2007 Evaluation of a manual energy curtain for tomato production in high tunnels HortTechnology 17 467 472
Byczynski, L. 2003 The hoop-house handbook. Growing For Market, Lawrence, KS
Calvert, A. 1964 The effects of air temperature on growth of young tomato plants in natural light conditions J. Hort. Sci. 39 194 211
Carey, E.E., Jett, L., Lamont, W.J. Jr, Nennich, T.T., Orzolek, M.D. & Williams, K.A. 2009 Horticultural crop production in high tunnels in the United States: A snapshot HortTechnology 19 37 43
Chism, J. 2002 Warm-season vegetable production in high tunnels. The Kerr Center for Sustainable Agriculture. 21 Dec. 2011. <http://www.kerrcenter.com/publications/2002_proceedings/warm-season_veggies.pdf>
Creswell, T., Ruhl, G., Faghihi, J., Weller, S., Aly, B. & Masiunas, J. 2011 Midwest vegetable production guide for commercial growers. 21 Dec. 2011. <http://www.btny.purdue.edu/Pubs/ID/ID-56>
Csizinszky, A.A. 2005 Production in the open field, p. 237–252. In: Heuvelink, E. (ed.). Tomatoes. CABI Publishing, Oxfordshire, UK
Emmert, E.M. 1956 Plastic row covering for producing extra-early vegetables outdoors. Univ. of Kentucky Agr. Ext. Serv. Leaflet 167
Gent, M.P.N. 1992 Yield response to planting date, ventilation and soil temperature on growth and nutrition of tomato high tunnels Plant Soil 145 81 91
Gent, M.P.N. & Melerba, V. 1994 Heating soil with hot air improves early yield and quality of greenhouse tomatoes HortTechnology 4 277 281
Gent, M.P.N. & Ma, Y.-Z. 1998 Diurnal temperature variation of the root and shoot affects yield of greenhouse tomato HortScience 33 47 51
Gent, M.P.N., Thorne, J.H. & Aylor, D.E. 1979 Split-night temperatures in a greenhouse: The effects on the physiology and growth of plants. Connecticut Agricultural Experiment Station Bulletin B781
Gosselin, A. & Trudel, M.J. 1985 Influence of root-zone temperature on growth, development and yield of cucumber plants cv. Toska Plant Soil 85 327 336
Hanna, H.Y. & Henderson, E.D. 2008 Fuel type and releasing the heated air near plant roots reduced production cost of greenhouse tomatoes HortTechnology 18 290 294
Hunter, B., Drost, D. & Ward, R. 2011 High tunnel early tomato budget. Utah State Univ. Coop. Ext. 21 Dec. 2011. <http://extension.usu.edu/agribusiness/files/uploads/specialty/pdf/2011%20Early%20Tomato%20High%20Tunnel%20.pdf>
Hurd, R.G. & Graves, C.J. 1985 Some effects of air and root temperatures on the yield and quality of glasshouse tomatoes J. Hort. Sci. 60 359 371
Hurewitz, J., Maletta, M. & Janes, H.W. 1984 The effects of root-zone heating at normal and cool air temperatures on growth and photosynthetic rates of tomatoes Acta Hort. 148 871 876
Janes, H.W. & McAvoy, R. 1983 Deleterious effects of cool air temperature reversed by root-zone warming in poinsettia HortScience 18 363 364
Jett, L.W. 2004 Production of tomatoes within a high tunnel. 21 Dec. 2011. <http://www.hightunnels.org/ForGrowers/WarmSeasonVegetables/warmseasonvegtomprod.htm>
Kinet, J.M. & Peet, M.M. 1997 Tomato. In: Wien, H.C. (ed.). The physiology of vegetable crops. CAB International, New York, NY
Knewtson, S.J.B., Carey, E.E. & Kirkham, M.B. 2010 Management practices of growers using high tunnels in the central Great Plains of the United States HortTechnology 20 639 645
Koester, K. 2003 Greenhouse raspberry production guide. Dept. of Horticulture, Cornell University Publication 23. 21 Dec. 2011. <http://www.agrireseau.qc.ca/petitsfruits/Documents/ghrasp.pdf>
Krizek, D.T., Saftner, R., Park, E., Abbott, J., Camp, M. & Clark, D. 2006 Yield data from 2005 and instrumental and sensory evaluation of tomato fruits from plants grown in high tunnels at Beltsville, MD, or obtained from commercial sources HortScience 41 1083
Lamont, W.J., Orzolek, M.D., Rasmussen, C. & White, L. 2005 High tunnel production manual. 2nd Ed. Pennsylvania State University, Dept. of Hort. Ext Publ. High Tunnel Ser. 1, State College, PA
Moller, A.L. & Gillies, R.R. 2008 Utah climate. 2nd Ed. Utah Climate Center, Logan, UT
Papadopoulos, A.P. & Tiessen, H. 1983 Root and air temperature effects on the flowering and yield of tomato J. Amer. Soc. Hort. Sci. 108 805 809
Peterson, R.H. & Taber, H.G. 1991 Tomato flowering and early yield response to heat buildup under rowcovers J. Amer. Soc. Hort. Sci. 116 206 209
Reiss, E., Both, A.J., Carrison, S., Kline, W. & Sudal, J. 2004 Season extension for tomato production using high tunnels Acta Hort. 659 153 160
Rowley, D., Black, B.L., Drost, D. & Feuz, D. 2010 Early-season extension using June-bearing ‘Chandler’ strawberry in high-elevation high tunnels HortScience 45 1464 1469
Shedlosky, M.E. & White, J.W. 1987 Growth of bedding plants in response to root-zone heating and night temperature regimes J. Amer. Soc. Hort. Sci. 112 290 295
USDA-AMS 1991 United States standards for grades of fresh tomatoes. 21 Dec. 2011 <http://www.ams.usda.gov/AMSv1.0/getfile?dDocName=STELPRDC5050331>
Waggoner, P.E. 1958 Protecting plants from the cold. Connecticut Agr. Expt. Sta. Issue 614, New Haven, CT
Ward, R., Drost, D. & Whyte, A. 2011 Assessing profitability of selected specialty crops grown in high tunnels J. Agribusiness 29 41 58
Wells, O.S. & Loy, J.B. 1993 Rowcovers and high tunnels enhance crop production in the northeastern United States HortTechnology 3 92 95
Wilcox, S. & Marion, W. 1994 U.S. solar radiation resource maps. National Renewable Energy Laboratory. 21 Dec. 2011. <http://rredc.nrel.gov/solar/old_data/nsrdb/1961-1990/redbook/atlas/>
Wolfe, D.W., Albright, L.D. & Wyland, J. 1989 Modeling row cover effects on microclimate and yield: I. Growth response of tomato and cucumber J. Amer. Soc. Hort. Sci. 114 562 568