Chemical thinning is practiced in most tree fruit-growing areas around the world. It is the easiest, most practical and cost-effective way to reduce cropload on heavily cropping trees (Wertheim, 1997; Williams and Edgerton, 1981). Reduction in the number of fruit to a more favorable leaf-to-fruit ratio allows high-quality fruit to be produced in the current year and improves bloom the next year. There is an ongoing search for new thinning chemicals that have different modes of action. This search has been prompted by the withdrawal of some fruit thinners and fueled by consumer-driven concerns for food safety, thus stimulating a search for environmentally friendly and naturally occurring compounds (Dennis, 2000). Furthermore, there are fewer thinners that are available for use on or are effective on pears than on apples.
Recently there has been increased interest in understanding the way(s) chemical thinners cause fruit abscission (Greene, 2010). It is reasoned that greater understanding of the modes of action will lead to more consistent and effective results (Fallahi and Greene, 2010). This would be accomplished primarily by allowing use or application at times and under environmental conditions that would naturally supplement the natural tendencies of the compound to cause abscission. Several possible modes of action have been proposed for the presently used thinners (Dennis, 2002). Therefore, matching the thinner, timing, concentration, and the cultivar and with the environmental conditions at the time of and immediately after application is likely to improve the consistency of the chosen thinner (Robinson and Lakso, 2011). A fairly substantial body of evidence has accumulated in recent years linking the carbohydrate status within a tree with thinning effectiveness and severity (Byers et al., 1991; Kondo and Takahashi, 1987; Lakso, 2011; Stopar et al., 2001). Cited modes of action of naphthaleneacetic acid (Stopar et al., 1997), benzyladenine (Yuan and Greene, 2000), and carbaryl (Knight, 1983; Williams and Batjer, 1964) suggested that they all or in part work through their influence on the carbohydrate status within the tree or spur.
Abscisic acid is a naturally occurring plant hormone that is involved in several physiological responses (Milborrow, 1984). Perhaps one of the most visible and important plant processes that it regulates is stomatal opening and closing. The ability of ABA to regulate stomatal movement led to the development of a proprietary product that, among other things, is meant to improve plant survival by lowering water loss by closing stomata when plants are exposed to stressful conditions that may lead to excessive water loss (Blanchard et al., 2007; Waterland et al., 2010). ABA has the potential to influence the carbohydrate status within a plant by closing stomates, thus reducing photosynthesis during the time the stomates are closed. It is for this reason that ABA was evaluated as a thinner on apples, and it was found to be quite an effective abscission-promoting compound (Greene et al., 2011).
Benzyladenine is the most recently registered thinner for use on apples (Greene, 2002). It was subsequently registered for use on pears. In general higher rates are used on pears than are generally recommended for use on apple (Vilardell et al., 2005). BA has been reported to thin several pear cultivars including Clara Frijs (Bertelsen, 2002), Bartlett (Curetti et al., 2011; Dussi and Sugar, 2011), Packham’s Triumph (Bound and Mitchell, 2002), and Conference (Maas et al., 2010; Vilardell et al., 2005). A mixture of thinning compounds is frequently recommended for use on apples because combinations are perceived to be a safer approach to thinning because lower rates of the individual thinners may be used and different thinner modes of action are involved (Greene, 2002; Schwallier, 1996; Williams and Edgerton, 1981). This strategy has been particularly effective when BA is combined with other thinners such as carbaryl on apples. Maas et al. (2010) reported that BA alone was a marginal thinner on ‘Conference’ pear but when combined with 1-naphthaleneacetic acid (NAA), significant thinning was achieved along with enhanced return bloom. The combination of ABA and BA as a thinning spray was used by Greene et al. (2011) on apples not only to improve thinner response, but also counteract the leaf yellowing and leaf abscission (Greene et al., 2011) effect caused by the ABA on some apple cultivars.
This investigation was undertaken for several reasons: 1) to determine if ABA might be a useful thinner on pears; 2) to determine the most effective time(s) of application; 3) to evaluate ABA and BA thinner combination; and 4) to determine if BA could counteract leaf yellowing and abscission that are frequently induced by ABA.
Addicutt, F.T. & Lyon, J.L. 1969 Physiology of abscisic acid and related substances, p. 139–164. In: Briggs, Greene, Jones (eds.). Annual Reviews Inc., Palo Alto, CA
Beardsell, M.E. & Cohen, D. Relationship between leaf water status, abscisic acid levels, and stomatal resistance in maize and sorghum Plant Physiol. 56 207 212
Blanchard, M.G., Newton, L.A., Runkle, E.S., Woodard, D. & Campbell, C.A. 2007 Exogenous application of abscisic acid improves the postharvest drought tolerance of several annual bedding plants Acta Hort. 755 127 132
Byers, R.E., Barden, J.A. & Carbaugh, D.H. 1990a Thinning of spur Delicious apples by shade, terbecil, carbaryl, and ethephon J. Amer. Soc. Hort. Sci. 115 9 13
Byers, R.E., Barden, J.A., Young, R.F. & Carbaugh, D.H. 1990b Apple thinning by photosynthetic inhibition J. Amer. Soc. Hort. Sci. 115 14 19
Curetti, M., Rodriguez, R., Magdalena, C. & Rodriguez, A. 2011 Effect of concentration and the addition of a surfactant to the response of benzyladenine as a thinning agent of ‘Williams’ pears Acta Hort. 909 395 401
Dussi, M.C. & Sugar, D. 2011 Fruit thinning and fruit size enhancement with 6-benzyladenine application to ‘Williams’ pear Acta Hort. 909 403 407
Fallahi, E. & Greene, D.W. 2010 Impact of bloom and postbloom thinners on fruit set and fruit quality in apples and stone fruit Acta Hort. 884 179 187
Greene, D.W., Schupp, J.R. & Winzler, H.W. 2011 Effect of abscisic acid and benzyladenine on fruit set and fruit quality of apples HortScience 46 1 6
Kondo, S. & Takahashi, Y. 1987 Effects of high temperature in the night time and shading in the daytime on the early drop of apple fruit ‘Starking Delicious’ J. Jpn. Soc. Hort. Sci. 56 142 150
McArtney, S., White, M., Latter, I. & Campbell, J. 2004 Individual and combined effects of shading and thinning chemicals on abscission and dry-matter accumulation of ‘Royal Gala’ apple fruit J. Hort. Sci. Biotechnol. 79 441 448
McLaughlin, J.M. & Greene, D.W. 1984 Effect of BA, GA4+7, and daminozide on fruit set, fruit quality, vegetative growth, flower initiation, and flower quality of ‘Golden Delicious’ apple J. Amer. Soc. Hort. Sci. 109 34 39
Milborrow, B.V. 1984 Inhibitors, p. 76–110. In: Wilkins, M.B. (ed.). Advanced plant physiology. Pitman Publishing Ltd., London, UK
Schwallier, P.G. 1996 Apple thinning guide. Great Lakes Publishing Co., Sparta, MI
Stopar, M., Black, B.L. & Bukovac, M.J. 1997 The effect of NAA and BA on carbon dioxide assimilation by shoot leaves of spur-type ‘Delicious’ and ‘Empire’ apple trees J. Amer. Soc. Hort. Sci. 122 837 840
Stopar, M., Resnik, M. & Pongrac, V.Z. 2001 Non-structural carbohydrate status and CO2 exchange rate of apple fruitlets at the time of abscission influenced by shade, NAA or BA Sci. Hort. 87 65 76
Van Staden, J., Cook, E. & Nooden, L.D. 1988 Cytokinins and senescence, p. 281–328. In: Nooden, L.D. and A.C. Leopold (eds.). Senescence and aging in plants. Academic Press Inc., San Diego, CA
Vilardell, P., Carbo, J., Casals, M., Bonany, J., Asin, L. & Dalmau, R. 2005 Effect of 6-BA and NAA as thinning agents of ‘Conference’ pear Acta Hort. 671 119 124
Waterland, N.L., Campbell, C.A., Finer, J.J. & Jones, M. 2010 Abscisic acid application enhances drought stress tolerance in bedding plants HortScience 45 409 413
Williams, M.W. & Batjer, L.P. 1964 Site and mode of action of 1-napthyl N- methylcarbomates (Sevin) in thinning apples Proc. Amer. Soc. Hort. Sci. 85 1 10
Williams, M.W. & Edgerton, L.J. 1981 Fruit thinning of apples and pears with chemicals. U.S. Dept. Agr. Bul. 289, Washington, DC
Yuan, R. & Greene, D.W. 2000 Benzyladenine as a chemical thinner for ‘McIntosh’ apples. I. Fruit thinning effects and associated relationships with photosynthesis, assimilate translocation, and non-structural carbohydrates J. Amer. Soc. Hort. Sci. 125 169 176