Turf lawns are estimated to cover roughly 2% of the continental United States (Milesi et al., 2005), mostly in highly urban areas. Although management of lawns varies by function and individual manager, it is typically characterized by three primary cultural practices: mowing, fertilizing, and irrigation (Turgeon, 1999). These practices are intended to favor turf species and, when applied in tandem with proper establishment techniques, result in stands of uniform turf. Despite lawns being currently managed as uniform monocultures, they are often host to flowering plants that provide foraging resources for bees and other pollinators. A recent insect survey of park lawns hosting dandelion (Taraxacum officinale F.H. Wigg.) and white clover (Trifolium repens L.) conducted in Lexington, Kentucky (Larson et al., 2014), found 37 associated bee species. These plant species are typically considered weeds in the United States and are sometimes eliminated through the use of broadleaf herbicides. However, lawns managed intentionally for forb abundance and richness would likely have a beneficial impact to local foraging bee communities. Previous research has suggested a strong positive relationship between forb community richness and pollinator community richness that likely extends to lawn communities as well (Ebeling et al., 2008; Potts et al., 2003). Such management goals would necessitate the reduction of other lawn inputs and would further the goal of increased sustainability. Mowing often correlates negatively with plant species richness in lawns (Bertoncini et al., 2012; Garbuzov et al., 2014; Lerman et al., 2018; Shwartz et al., 2013; Smith and Fellowes, 2015), and managing floral lawns could lead to less-intensive mowing regimes. The inclusion of legumes such as white clover has shown to enhance turf nitrogen uptake through nitrogen fixation (McCurdy et al., 2014; Sincik and Acikgoz, 2007), and would potentially reduce fertilizer inputs into lawns.
At the other extreme of flowering lawns, researchers as the University of Reading in the United Kingdom have abandoned the use of turfgrasses altogether, and have been developing species lists and management practice guidelines for purely floral lawns (Smith and Fellowes, 2015) that have been found to have benefits to flower-visiting insects (Smith et al., 2014). These lawns may provide benefits to flower-visiting insects, but they are not meant to be areas of high human traffic and recreation. Human traffic on monocultures of white clover was found to reduce green cover up to 14 times faster when compared with hybrid bermudagrass [Cynodon transvaalensis Burtt- Davy 3 C. dactylon (L.) Pers.], suggesting the importance in turfgrasses for maintaining long-term cover in variable traffic conditions (Brosnan et al., 2014). Another potential challenge of these nonturfgrass plantings is the reliance on precultivation and installation, which can be costly on a large scale, and the potential need for more specialized care. In addition, there is still a strong cultural connection with turf lawns (Harris et al., 2013), and an intermediate flowering lawn that combines turfgrass and floral species may have broader and more practical appeal, especially for recreational use. For these reasons, grass–forb mixes established from seed are an important area of focus for future research. This type of floral-enhanced lawn should provide quick groundcover, reduce lawn maintenance, save money, and provide typical lawn functions such as recreation.
Although floral lawns hold great promise in improving biodiversity in urban areas, guidelines for establishing usable forbs in a lawn are needed to encourage adoption. The main objective of this study was to identify a turfgrass species that would allow for better success in the introduction of flowers not typically thought of as turf weeds. An ideal turfgrass species would maintain groundcover, but also allow for establishment and bloom of its forb companions. Some effort has been made into developing seeding strategies for white clover into established lawns to benefit pollinators and soil nitrogen (McCurdy et al., 2013; Sparks et al., 2015). White clover is an established agronomic crop that is widely associated with pasture agriculture, and is well adapted to the grazing systems under which it evolved (Leffel and Gibson, 1973). Pasture systems and lawns are similar in many ways, (e.g., compaction and cutting by animals or humans) and it is no surprise that white clover does well in both environments. So although white clover is a viable option for improving lawn floral abundance, more forb options are needed to improve the diversity and conservation value of turfgrass lawns.
To understand more fully how turfgrass species influence other forbs, we selected four common turfgrass species used in home lawns in the northern United States to mix with a species of clover: Kura clover (Trifolium ambiguum M. Bieb.). Kura clover is a rhizomatous perennial plant originating from eastern Europe/western Asia and has been investigated as a cold-tolerant forage plant for pasture cattle in the United States. Kura clover is not commonly cultivated across the United States, but it can be found growing infrequently in seminatural areas. Kura clover is known for its slow establishment period and sensitivity to grass competition (Hill and Mulcahy, 1995; Seguin et al., 1999) when used under pasture conditions. Kura clover’s agronomic properties, such as high seed germination rates and grazing tolerance, combined with its sensitivity to competition make it an ideal model species for isolating how competitive pressure from different turf species might affect the establishment and bloom of flowering plants not typically associated with turfgrass lawns.
We predicted that slow-establishing and nonrhizomatous turf species would favor Kura clover establishment and bloom, whereas fast-establishing and rhizomatous species would disfavor Kura establishment and bloom. Our primary goal was to identify turfgrass species that can be seeded at their recommended rates while minimizing turfgrass species-specific competitive effects. Identifying turfgrass species more amenable to forb species additions is important to subsequent studies aimed at identifying other limiting factors in forb establishment, such as germination and mowing tolerance. This is the first of a series of studies that aims to provide foraging resources for pollinating insects in turf lawns.
BeauregardM.S.SeguinP.SheafferC.C.GrahamP.H.2003Characterization and evaluation of North American Trifolium ambiguum-nodulating rhizobiaBiol. Fert. Soils38311318
BertinC.SenesacA.F.RossiF.S.DiTommasoA.WestonL.A.2009Evaluation of selected fine-leaf fescue cultivars for their turfgrass quality and weed suppressive ability in field settingsHortTechnology19660668
BrosnanJ.T.DicksonK.H.SorochanJ.C.ThomsA.W.StierJ.C.2014Large crabgrass, white clover, and hybrid bermudagrass athletic field playing quality in response to simulated trafficCrop Sci.541838
ChristiansN.E.PattonA.J.LawQ.D.2017Fundamentals of turfgrass Management. 5th ed. Wiley Hoboken NJ
DeBelsB.T.GriffithS.E.KreuserW.C.MelbyE.S.SoldatD.J.2012Evaluation of mowing height and fertilizer application rate on quality and weed abundance of five home lawn grassesWeed Technol.26826831
EbelingA.KleinA.-M.SchumacherJ.WeisserW.W.TscharntkeT.2008How does plant richness affect pollinator richness and temporal stability of flower visits?Oikos11718081815
Froud-WilliamsR.J.ChancellorR.J.DrennanD.S.H.1983Influence of cultivation regime upon buried weed seeds in arable cropping systemsAppl. Ecol.20199208
GarbuzovM.FensomeK.A.RatnieksF.L.W.2014Public approval plus more wildlife: Twin benefits of reduced mowing of amenity grass in a suburban public park in Saltdean, UKInsect Conserv. Divers.
HarrisE.M.MartinD.G.PolskyC.DenhardtL.NehringA.2013Beyond “lawn people”: The role of emotions in suburban yard management practicesProf. Geogr.65345361
HillM.J.MulcahyC.1995Seedling vigour and rhizome development in Trifolium ambiguum M. Bieb. (Caucasian Clover) as affected by density of companion grasses, fertility, drought and defoliation in the first yearAustral. J. Agr. Res.46807819
LabergeG.MaboodF.SeguinP.2005Kura clover early growth is comparable to that of white clover when not nitrogen limitedJ. Plant Nutr.28447457
LarsonJ.L.KesheimerA.J.PotterD.A.2014Pollinator assemblages on dandelions and white clover in urban and suburban lawnsJ. Insect Conserv.18863873
LaskeyB.C.WakefieldR.C.1978Competitive effects of several grass species and weeds on the establishment of birdsfoot trefoilAgron. J.70146148
LeffelR.C.GibsonP.B.1973White clover p. 167–176. In: Forages: The science of grassland agriculture
LermanS.B.ContostaA.R.MilamJ.BangC.2018To mow or to mow less: Lawn mowing frequency affects bee abundance and diversity in suburban yardsBiol. Conserv.221160174
McCurdyJ.D.McElroyJ.S.GuertalE.A.HallF.2013White clover (Trifolium repens) establishment within dormant bermudagrass turf: Cultural considerations, establishment timing, seeding rate, and cool-season companion grass speciesHortScience4815561561
McCurdyJ.D.McElroyJ.S.GuertalE.A.WoodC.W.2014White clover inclusion within a bermudagrass lawn: Effects of supplemental nitrogen on botanical composition and nitrogen cyclingCrop Sci.5417961803
MilesiC.RunningS.W.ElvidgeC.D.DietzJ.B.TuttleB.T.Nemani.R.R.2005Mapping and modeling the biogeochemical cycling of turf grasses in the United StatesEnviron. Manage.36426438
MorrisK.N.20162005 National Kentucky bluegrass test 2006–10 data final report. NTEP No. 11-10. 2011
PottsS.G.VulliamyB.DafniA.Ne’emanG.WillmerP.2003Linking bees and flowers: How do floral communities structure pollinator communities?Ecology8426282642
SeguinP.SheafferC.C.EhlkeN.J.RusselleM.P.GrahamP.H.2001Nitrogen fertilization and rhizobial inoculation effects on Kura clover growthAgron. J.9312621268
ShwartzA.MuratetA.SimonL.JulliardR.2013Local and management variables outweigh landscape effects in enhancing the diversity of different taxa in a big metropolisBiol. Conserv.157285292
SincikM.AcikgozE.2007Effects of white clover inclusion on turf characteristics, nitrogen fixation, and nitrogen transfer from white clover to grass species in turf mixturesCommun. Soil Sci. Plant Anal.3818611877
SmithL.S.BroylesM.E.J.LarzleerH.K.FellowesM.D.E.2014Adding ecological value to the urban lawnscape: Insect abundance and diversity in grass-free lawnsBiodivers. Conserv.244762
SparksB.MunshawG.WilliamsD.BarrettM.DriveV.WoosleyP.2015Preplant cultivation techniques and planting date effects on white clover establishment into an existing cool-season turfgrass swardHortScience50615620
SpringerT.L.1996Allelopathic effects on germination and seedling growth of clover by endophyte-free and -infected tall fescueCrop Sci.3616391642
TurgeonA.J.1999Turfgrass management. 5th ed. Prentice Hall Upper Saddle River NJ
VandevenderJ.2003Kura clover planting guide. Natural Resource Conservation Service Plant Materials Center Alderson WV